Chiswell-Bucktrout House Historical Report, Block 2 Building 17 Lot 253-254Originally entitled: "Chiswell-Bucktrout House, Francis Street, Block 2"

Mary A. Stephenson

1965

Colonial Williamsburg Foundation Library Research Report Series - 1017
Colonial Williamsburg Foundation Library

Williamsburg, Virginia

1990

CHISWELL-BUCKTROUT HOUSE
Francis Street
Block 2

Mary A. Stephenson

February, 1965

Summaryi
Summary of ownershipiii
Tyler's Map of Williamsburg Frontispiece
Location1
History1-32
Illustration #1
Archaeologists Drawing - Foundations33
Bucktrout Map34
Archaeologists Drawing - Plot Plan35
Illustration #2
Excerpts from Williamsburg Land Tax Records36
Illustration #3
Biographical Sketches of:
Lemuel J. Bowden38
The Reverend John Bracken39
Benjamin Bucktrout41
Colonel John Chiswell47
Anthony Robinson49
John Robinson 50
James Barret Southall51
Dr. Richard Alsop Wise52
Illustration #4
Excerpts from:
Jerdone Papers 1750-175253
Alexr Craig Account Book (1761-1766)54
Edmund Pendleton 172 1 1-1803, A Biography55
Galt-Barraud Medical Account Books 56
Illustration #5
Archaeological drawing, Area H-1157
Memo from Mr. I. Noël Hume 58
Facing Page
Mrs. John Chiswell3
John Robinson, The Speaker5
The Freeman House (1929)31

CHISWELL-BUCKTROUT HOUSE
Francis Street
Block 2

LOCATION:

The house known as the "Chiswell-Bucktrout House" is situated on Francis Street in Williamsburg. The lots are marked "Chiswell" on Tyler's adaptation of the College Map (1791?) and on the Bucktrout Map (1807) of Williamsburg.

IN SUMMARY:

As the lots lie in that part of Williamsburg which was in James City County in the eighteenth century it is difficult if not impossible to get clear titles to the property as court records were largely destroyed by fire during the Civil War. The first known owner and occupant was Colonel John Chiswell who was on the location prior to 1766 at the time of his death. Following his decease, there was a sale of his property. Mrs. Chiswell, the widow, may have continued to live there until the sale in 1770. Sometime prior to 1779 Benjamin Bucktrout, carpenter and cabinet-maker, apparently, had acquired the property. In 1774 he had been located on Francis Street. Present records do not justify stating that he was on this property then though any new data may give this information. In 1777 Bucktrout had a store somewhere in the city and a small powder mill. In August, 1779 he offered the property for sale noting that it was "where the subscriber lives, formerly belonging to Colonel Chiswell." William Davenport, a tavern keeper, opened and operated at this location in 1779. Monsieur Jean Cadou, dancing master, advertised that he could be found "at Davenport's" and Monsieur de Chef de Bien, limner, offered his talents, also, "at Mr. William Davenport's." As Bucktrout in 1782 owned only 1/4 lot in the city according to the tax records, it would seem that he had sold the Chiswell property. However, in 1782 James Southall, a tavern keeper, was owner of the property from ii 1782 to 1806. Anthony Robinson held the property until 1814 when he conveyed to the Reverend John Bracken, president of William and Mary College who lived thereon until his death in 1818. His daughter, Mrs. Julia Bracken Avery, lived on the property until her death in 1835. Prior to 1840 Mrs. Susan Byrd had purchased it though, most probably, she never owned it in fee simple. Lemuel J. Bowden became the owner in 1841. He held it until around the Civil War when he moved into a new house on Duke of Gloucester Street near the Church. A gap in title occurs until 1889 when James L. Slater was owner. In 1895 Slater sold to Richard A. Wise. He or his heirs held until 1922 when it was conveyed to S. D. Freeman. In 1928 the property was bought by Dr. W. A. R. Goodwin representing Williamsburg Restoration. The Frenchman's Map (1782) shows a very long house on this site with two outbuildings to the south. The plats of the city made ca. 1807 by Bucktrout and the College Map (1791?) indicate the name "Chiswell."

CHISWELL-BUCKTROUT HOUSE
Francis Street
Block 2.

DateOwned ByDateOccupied ByProfession
1766Col. John Chiswell or estate1766-1770Chiswell familyColonel in Army Burgess
1770Mrs. Chiswell & Jno. Robinson Est.1770-
1776 Benj. Bucktrout(?)1776-1779BucktroutCabinet-maker
1779Wm. DavenportTavern-keeper
Monsieur CadouDancing Master
Monsieur Chef de BienLimner
1782James Southall1782-1805James SouthallTavern-keeper (Residence)
1806Anthony Robinson1806-1814Robinson familyLawyer
1814Jno. Bracken or Estate1814-1840Bracken familyMinister & President Wm. & Mary College
1818-1835Mrs. Julia Bracken Avery
1835-1840 McCandlish family.
1839(?)Mrs. Susan Byrd
1840Lemuel J. Bowden1840-1859Bowden family Lawyer
1888Bowden heirs(unknown renters)
1889James L. Slater1889-1895Slater family
1895Richard A. Wise1895-1901Wise familyPhysician
1901Wise heirs1901-1922(Renters Unknown)
1922S. D. Freeman1922-1928Freeman familyMajor
1928W. A. R. Goodwin rep. Williamsburg Restoration1928-(Leased to Freeman for 5 years)

RR101701Photostat Copy of the Williamsburg Plat in "Williamsburg the Old Colonial Capitol" by Lyon G. Tyler

CHISWELL-BUCKTROUT HOUSE
Block 2

LOCATION:

The Chiswell-Bucktrout house is located on the south side of Francis Street in Williamsburg near the Capitol. See: Tyler's adaptation of the College Map (1791?) opposite page. The lots are marked "Chiswell."

HISTORY:

Nearly all deeds or wills relating to lots in James City county court records or in the General Court records were destroyed during the Civil War. This precludes any chance of giving a clear title to these lots. From scattered evidence such as newspapers, family papers, suits and a few statutes, it has been possible to interpret the ownership of these lots only from ca. 1766 to the present.

Available facts point to Colonel John Chiswell1 as the first owner of whom there is any record. Just when or how he came into possession cannot be said, nor can we 2 know, definitely, if he was owner in fee simple. However, sometime prior to 1766 Chiswell was living at this location on Francis Street.1

Colonel Chiswell was a member of the House of Burgesses from Hanover County from 1742-1758. He represented Williamsburg from 1756-1758. He owned property in Williamsburg as early as 1752. In August, 1752, he and George Gilmer bought the Raleigh Tavern from Alexander Finnie.2 There are accounts of "Messrs Chiswell & Gilmer in Williamsburg" with Francis Jerdone, merchant at Yorktown, in 1751-'52; "Col. John Chiswell of Williamsburg" in 1754; and "Col John Chiswell" 1751.3 From 1752-1766, Chiswell had slaves baptized in Bruton Parish.4 Sometime prior to 1761 Colonel Chiswell owned lots 329-331 on Palace Green.5 From 1761-'63 Chiswell had accounts with RR101702Mrs. John Chiswell (c. 1722-1776) daughter of William Randolph II (1681-1741) of "Turkey Island." Front a portrait (by John Wollaston, the younger) in Virginia Historical Society, Richmond. By courtesy Brick Art Reference Library, New York
H. J. Eckenrode, The Randolphs, 1946, p. 36.
3 Alexander Craig, sadler, in the city.1

The Chiswells occupied a prominent place in the community of Williamsburg. She was a daughter of William Randolph of "Turkey Island"; he was a son of Charles Chiswell, once Clerk of the General Court. Susannah Chiswell, daughter of Colonel and Mrs. Chiswell married Speaker and Treasurer John Robinson.2 Together with Robinson, William Byrd and Governor Fauquier, Colonel Chiswell owned valuable lead mines in Wythe County. In the opinion of Dr. Kenneth McKenzie, Mrs. Chiswell ranked with Mrs. Dinwiddie, and "Mrs. Attorney," wife of John Randolph, —— for he requested "Mrs. Dinwiddie, Mrs. Attorney and Mrs. Chiswell or one of them to take her [his young daughter] under their care for a year or two in order to her further improvement"3 "Mr. Attorney" was the first cousin to Mrs. Chiswell; her aunt was Mrs. William Stith, wife of 4 the president of William and Mary College and her brother, Peter Randolph, was a member of the Council.

In 1766 while in a tavern in Cumberland county, John Chiswell quarrelled with a Scotch merchant, Robert Rutledge, and called him "a fugitive rebel, a villain who came to Virginia to cheat and defraud men of their property, and a Presbyterian fellow..." according to one witness.1 Chiswell killed Rutledge, was arrested, and was let out of jail on bail by three friends, John Blair, Presley Thornton and William Byrd. Chiswell's death on October 15, 1766 before the time of the trial, was explained by John Randolph thus:

On Wednesday last (15th) about 2 P.M. died at his House in this city Col. John Chiswell, after a short illness. The causes of his death by the Judge't of his physicians upon oath, were nervous fits owing to constant uneasiness of the mind. [The editor adds, "Notwithstanding this he is believed to have committed suicide."]2

RR101703John Robinson, The Speaker
From the Original Portrait by John Wollaston, now in the possession of J. Taylor Robinson, Richmond, Virginia
Canvas measures 36x29 inches.
Alexander Welbourne Weddell, ed., Virginia Historical Portraiture 1585-1830, 1930, p. 169.

5

Speaker John Robinson, Chiswell's son-in-law, died on May 11th 1766 just a few months prior to Colonel Chiswell's death.1 As Robinson owed the state over £100,000 as Treasurer, an Act was passed in November, 1769 "for the more speedy and effectual recovery of the debt to the public from the estate of the late treasurer":

I . …It is hereby enacted by the authority of the same, (Assembly] That Edmund Pendleton and Peter Lyons, gentlemen, surviving administrators of the said John Robinson, or the survivor of them, shall, within six months from the passing of this act, fairly sell and dispose of all the lands, slaves, goods and chattels, and other estate of which the said John Robinson died seized and possessed, for all the interest which the said John Robinson had therein, or which he might lawfully part with, except the dower, of Susanna Robinson, his widow, upon twelve months credit, for the best price that can be had, and convey the same to the purchaser or purchasers in fee simple, who shall thereafter respectively hold the same, discharged of the title of the said John Robinson, and his heirs, and all claiming under him.

II. …

III. And be it further enacted, by the authority aforesaid, That the money to be raised, by virtue of this act, shall be accounted for by the said Edmund Pendleton and Peter Lyons [executors], and after deducting the expences of sale and collection, shall be paid to Robert Carter Nicholas, esq; treasurer of this colony, or to the treasurer for 6 the time being,…to be by him applied towards the redemption of the treasury notes, and accounted for to the general assembly, until the balance due from the estate of the said John Robinson to the public, with the interest thereof, is fully paid and discharged; and when that is done, the surplus, if any, shall be applied in a legal course of administration of the said estate. And whereas part of the said John Robinson's lands are subject to the dower of Mrs. Elizabeth Chiswell; and if that dower should be laid off, and if the dower of the said Susanna Robinson should be assigned in each particular tract of land, it might prejudice the sales thereof, and it would be beneficial to the public and enhance the sale if the said Edmund Pendleton and Peter Lyons were allowed to compound for the said dowers:

IV. Be it therefore enacted, by the authority aforesaid, That the said Edmund Pendleton and Peter Lyons shall have full power and authority to make any contract or contracts with the said Elizabeth Chiswell and Susanna Robinson, or either of them, for procuring their respective releases of dower in any of the lands of the said John Robinson, in which they are severally intitled to such dower, either by allotting them, and either of them, certain tracts of land in lieu of dower in the whole, or by allowing them the usual proportion of the money for which the lands shall sell, as to them shall appear just and equitable;...1

In 1768 Mrs. Chiswell paid 9 tithes, chariot tax and quit tax on 200 acres in James City County.2

7

In June, 1768 Miss Polly Chiswell married Warner Lewis, Jr., in Williamsburg.1 This would be further indication that the Chiswells had not removed from the house following Colonel Chiswell's death.

The provision of the Act calling for a sale was carried out on December 28, 1769, in a long announcement by Edmund Pendleton and Peter Lyons in the Virginia Gazette of the approaching sale of Robinson's plantations, and property in Williamsburg:

[December 28, 1769]

IN OBEDIENCE TO THE DIRECTION OF THE HOUSE OF BURGESSES, and by virtue of an act of the General Assembly of this colony, we shall proceed to sell all the estate of John Robinson, Esq; deceased, late Treasurer of Virginia, on twelve months credit… (date set for sale of Scotchtown, Mankahick, 4700 acres in Spotsylvania county, plantation below Morocosick bridge, "plantation where Mrs. Robinson now lives, lying on Mattapony river, in King and Queen county," Turner's warehouses &c, land belonging to the lead mines, Dismal Swamp company and other plantations…]

On Monday the 30th day of April will be sold on the premises, at Williamsburg, the houses and lots in the Back street, where Mrs. Chiswell now lives, which are conveniently and pleasantly situated, and so well known that it is useless to describe them. 8 At the same time and place will be sold, the household and kitchen furniture, and several fine SLAVES, chiefly house-servants; also a chariot and horses, some milch cows, &c…
EDMUND PENDLETON.
PETER LYONS.1

From the above two citations, we learn that Robinson owned property "in the Back street," in Williamsburg on which there were houses in which Mrs. Chiswell lived;2 that Mrs. Chiswell had dower rights; and that Mrs. Robinson did not live in Williamsburg but at her plantation on Mattapony river in King and Queen County.

A few days prior to the proposed sale, the administrators ran this notice in the Virginia Gazette which called attention to the sale:

[April 5, 1770]

On Monday the 30th of April will be SOLD at Williamsburg, on the premisses, THE HOUSES and LOTS in the back street, belonging to Mr. Robinson's estate, now in the occupation of Mrs. Chiswell, which are 9 pleasantly and conveniently situated; also the HOUSEHOLD and KITCHEN FURNITURE in and belonging to them, several valuable SLAVES, being the servants usually employed in and about the house and kitchen, a CHARIOT and HORSES, a good COACHMAN, some MILCH COWS &c. At the same time and place will be sold a TRACT of LAND in James City county,… Lilliput, adjoining the plantation of Mr. Benjamin Weldon, containing about 400 acres. [other property to be sold also]…1

The sale was held the last of April. Pendleton's accounts of administration show that Robinson's property in Williamsburg, "Lands had of Chiswell," brought £480:

SALES OF THE ROBINSON ESTATE Sales of the Estate of John Robinson Esqr.

Time of Sale Place of Sale Lands had of Chiswell Other Slaves…Lands 1770 April Williamsburg £480 £531 £843.11.02

No other accounts of the Chiswells in Williamsburg have been located in any records. Just who bought the property is not known. There is some reason to believe that Benjamin Bucktrout,3 cabinet-maker, may have purchased it 10 from the Chiswell estate.1 A strange item found in the Edward Charlton Account Book seems to indicate that Bucktrout paid "part House rent" to a Mr. Holt in 1776:

1776Mr Benjamin BucktroutDr
JanyTo five Years Shavg£5.0.0
To part House rent pay Mr. Holt13.6.8
2

Whether this bill was a past shaving account unpaid to Charlton and part rent to Holt as agent we do not know. We know from subsequent records to follow in the report that Bucktrout advertised "the House formerly Colonel Chiswell's" where he was then living (in 1779) for sale. (To follow chronologically in the report.)

We shall give Bucktrout's business-history in Williamsburg from 1771 to August, 1779:

[May 9, 1771]

Just IMPORTED, and to be SOLD cheap for ready Money, by the Subscriber, in WILLIAMSBURG, A NEAT and ELEGANT ASSORTMENT of PAPER HANGINGS, of various Kinds, and of the newest Fashions, 11 for Staircases, Rooms, and Ceilings; namely, embossed, Stocco, Chintz, striped, Mosaick, Damask, and common Rooms papered in the neatest Manner, and on reasonable Terms.
BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT.1

Sept. 17, 1771.

To be SOLD, any Time, betwixt this and October Court, for ready Money, SUNDRY fine PRINTS done by Mr. FRY, and some ELECTION PIECES By Hogarth, the Property of a Gentleman gone to England. They may be seen at any Time on applying to BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT.

N.B. Sundry neat PAPER HANGINGS to be sold ---
---Rooms neatly papered on reasonable Terms.

2

Williamsburg, July 4, 1774.

I HAVE for Sale, for ready Money, the following Articles, viz. MATTRESSES, made of the best English curled Hair, without any Addition of Tow or Wool; HAIR SEATING for Chairs; BOXES of TYPES for marking Linen, Books, &c. PAPER HANGINGS, of the best Kinds, and most fashionable Patterns. -- I have like wise to dispose of, the Remainder of the Time of an indented young Woman from Ireland, who was bred up as a Spinner in one of the first Linen Manufactures in that Kingdom; and the sole Reason of my parting with her is, my not having Employ for her,…
BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT.3

12

[October 27, 1774]

Just Imported, and to be SOLD cheap for ready Money, by the Subscriber in Francis Street, Williamsburg,
FINE Bottled Porter, Taunton Beer, Gloucester Cheese, Negro Plains, Kendal Cottons, Plain and Striped Blankets, Fine Lustrings of different Patterns, Yorkshire Cloths, Patterns for Mens Surtout Coats, with Trimmings to each, Mens fine and coarse Hats, Velvet bound Hats with Roses, Mens Boots, Womens and Childrens Leather Shoes, Mens Gloves, Womens fine French Kid Gloves, Guns, Silver mounted and plain Pistols, Saddles complete, Whips, Hair Brooms and Brushes, Wool and Playing Cards, Horn Lanthorns, Plaistering Trowels, Sets of Types for marking of Linen, Checks and Striped Holland, Pepper, Allspice, Ginger, Paper Hangings for Rooms, Best Durham Mustard, Blue and White Water Jugs, Chamber Pots, Quart and Pint Mugs, Milk Pans, Sage and Balm Tea Pots, Coffin Furniture, Hair Seating for Chairs, Matrasses, Glass Salts, Vinegar Cruits, Salt, &c. &c.
BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT.1

This is the first mention made as to Bucktrout's shop on Francis Street.

[February 4, 1775]

BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT,
CABINET MAKER, IN FRANCIS STREET, WILLIAMSBURG, STILL carries on that Business in all its Branches, where Ladies and Gentlemen may be supplied with any Sort of Cabinet Work in the best and neatest Manner…I return those Ladies 13 and Gentlemen who were pleased to favour me with their Commands, my most grateful Thanks, and hope for a Continuance of their Favours, which to merit shall always be the Study of their most humble Servant,
BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT.

N.B. I should be glad to take one or two Apprentices of bright Genuises, and of good Dispositions, and such whose Friends are willing to find them in Clothes.1

1

In 1775 the Virginia Military Treasury Account Book shows that Benjamin Bucktrout was paid for "iron potts for public use."2

On February 7, 1776 Bucktrout was paid "£77.6.9 for sundries for the Use of the army."3 And, on February 27, 1776, he was paid "£17.8.0 for 6 Guns furnished the public."4

On the 19th of February, [1776] John Page wrote to Richard Lee concerning a powder mill which Bucktrout, ingeniously, had erected in Williamsburg. Page highly endorsed the mill and stated that he would encourage Bucktrout "to go on with his work."

14

On February 19th John Page wrote to Richard Henry Lee:

"I moved too, with the like success, that the sum of £40 should be paid to Bucktrout, for his ingenuity in constructing, and to defray the expenses of erecting a powder mill; and to enable him to prosecute his plan of working up the Salt Petre which may be collected in the neighbouring Counties, with his Hand Powder Mill now at work in this City. The President [Pendleton] --- altho' I told the Committee I would engage to make 100 lbs of Powder per day with it, and endeavoured to show the necessity of encouraging such a work --- declared that in his opinion it was a Bauble, -- and 5 members were of opinion that it was not worth the reward I proposed. I was ashamed for the Committee, and very much hurt to find that my recommendation of a machine which I understood perfectly and had seen tried, and a man of whose ingenuity I had before produced proofs by showing powder of his making and proving its excellence by actual experiments, had not the least weight with the Committee. The mill, Sir, alone, well attended, might supply a great part of our Country with Powder. I shall do all I can to encourage the man to go on with his work. I think private subscriptions, until the Convention meets, may enable him to be very serviceable. The Committee indeed, on finding that many people in Town entertain an high opinion of this Mill, begin to appear willing to give some kind of encouragement to it."(Southern Literary Messenger, XXVII, 255.)1

A letter in the Lee Papers, February 20, 1776 — John Page to Richard Henry Lee, Williamsburg had this statement: 15 "Committee has ordered down the saltpetre which had been sent to Petersburg to be worked up by Bucktrout--hope this will encourage him to carry on manufacturing gun-powder to a large extent."1

Another letter of Page's to Thomas Jefferson continued to urge that Bucktrout's powder mill be taken into consideration and if possible, funds allotted to assist in operations:

"Wmsburg April the 26th. 1776

My dear Jefferson
Would you believe it, that we have not yet erected one Powder Mill at the public Expence, and that the only one which has received any Encouragement from the Public has made but about 700 lb., and that I have not been able to procure the least Assistance from the Committee for Bucktrout's hand-Mill, except their selling him about 400 lb. of Salt-petre of the Shops half dirt and common Salt for which they demand 3/ per lb., although his Mill is an elegant Machine and 2 Men can work it with ease, beating with 6 Pestles weighing 60 lbs. each in Mortars containing 20 lbs. of Paste, and he has actually beat 120 lb. of Powder in them and grained 40 lb. which has been used in proving Cannon &c. and which was found to be strong and good under every disadvantage of want of Sieves and being made with bad Sulphur and Nitre. And he has been at great Pains in erecting his Mill and Apparatus for it, and 16 for a Salt-petre work with it, yet the Committee of Safety refused any Motion to allow him 30 or 40 pounds as a Reward for his public Spirit and Ingenuity and to enable him to go on with his Plan. They insist on it that the premium of 6/ per lb. is sufficient Encouragement for making Gun powder, and are deaf to my Argument that Works of this Sort can not be erected and set a going without a good Stock of Money and that Premiums will do very well to keep up any Art once introduced, but are by no Means sufficient to introduce it into ready and general Use. This Powder Mill is so simple that if it were once cleverly at Work it would please every one who saw it, and would lead numbers of ingenious People to erect such in different Parts of the Country. There might be one in every Coun[ty] which in my Opinion might work up the Salt-petre which ought to be made in each County, and in this Manner Powder enough might be made for all America …. John Page"1

On February 27th, 1777 Page reported to Lee from Williamsburg: "…The two private Powder mills -- for there are none belonging to the public -- stand still for want of Saltpetre…"2

Research has not located Bucktrout's powder mill.

17

We do not know the location of Bucktrout's cabinet-making shop except it was "on Francis Street." We do not know where he made the powder as above described by John Page. On the extreme southern part of the lot, archaeological findings (1941) located long foundations (22' 10 3/8") with large fireplace (10' 7 ¼") at north end with another fireplace (smaller) at south end. An addition towards the south showed fireplace (2' 4 ¼"). See: drawing in Illustration #2 by James Knight. According to Mr. Knight, it was most unusual to find evidence of a brick building with three fireplaces. A smaller square building foundation (8'½") was found to the northwest of the building. To what use these buildings were put is not known. They may have been slave quarters or it is not impossible to think they may have been the cabinet making shop or possibly the combination of cabinetmaking and powder-mill shop. No artifacts were uncovered to add any light on the use to which this building was put.1

18

In February, 1777, Bucktrout had been appointed Purveyor and Steward to the Continental Hospital at Williamsburg: "And Benjamin Bucktrout is allowed two Dollars per Day for acting as Purveyor & Steward to the Hospital."1

Though "Joseph Hay had been appointed apothecary to the Hospital with the pay of two Dollars and four Rations per Day he being restricted from any private practice," it seems that Bucktrout was allowed to continue with his store: "a cargo of goods just imported from St. Eustatia [will] be sold at publick vendue, at Mr. Bucktrout's store in Williamsburg."2 And, in June, 1777 Bucktrout furnished rum at the meeting of the Botetourt Masonic Lodge in Williamsburg.3

In December, 1778, a warrant was issued by the Council "for Eight hundred pounds payable to Benjamin 19 Bucktrout upon Account as Purveyor to the Public Hospitals."1

In March, 1779 "Thomas Russell was appointed Purveyor of the Public Hospital in ye room of Benja Bucktrout who hath resigned."2

In August, 1779, Bucktrout offered for sale "the house formerly belonging to Colonel Chiswell" on Francis Street, as well as some of his household furniture and furnishings, cabinet-maker's tools, and seasoned wood for cabinetmaking and building -- the reason given that he expected to leave the state in October.

[August 28, 1779]

TO be sold betwixt this and the 27th of September, at private sale; the houses and lots where the subscriber lives, formerly belonging to Colonel Chiswell, it is very well calculated for a tavern as there is every necessary requisite, with a very good pasture joining. Also will be sold for ready money, on Wednesday the 22d of September, a variety of household and kitchen furniture, consisting of beds, bedding, mohogany chairs, tables, and chest of draws, hansome looking-glasses, Queen's china plates and dishes, ivory handled knives and forks, and an easy chair. Likewise two riding chairs and harness, two carts with harness for four horses, three very good 20 milch cows, three good chair horses, two mare colts,...a negro woman, who is an exceeding good washer and ironer; likewise will be sold a chest of cabinet makers and house joiners tools, with a quantity of very fine broad one, two, and three inch mohogany plank, which has been cut this five years, a parcel of shingles, pine and oak plank and scantling, nails of different sizes, window glass 8 by 10, and many other articles.

*** All persons indebted to the subscriber are desired to settle their accounts by the last of September; and those who have accounts are desired to apply for payment…. I intend leaving this state in October next.
BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT.

If the house is not sold by the time mentioned, it will be rented by the last of September, for which bond and security will be required by
B.B.1

1

William Davenport,2 tavern keeper, rented: 21

[October 2, 1779]

WILLIAM DAVENPORT
BEGS leave to inform the publick in general, and his friends in particular, that he has opened TAVERN in the house formerly occupied by Col. Chiswell, and lately by Benjamin Bucktrout, situate on the back street; and assures all those who please to favour him with their custom, that nothing in his power shall be lacking to give universal satisfaction. He has got good pasturage, but will not be answerable for horses that may stray or be stolen.1

Shortly after the above notice, two Frenchmen: one a dancing teacher; the other a limner, announced that they were lodging at William Davenport's:

[November 13, 1779]

MONSIEUR JEAN CADOU, takes this publick method of acquainting the Gentlemen and Ladies, that he intend opening a DANCING SCHOOL in this city. Those who choose to encourage him will please send or write to him at Mr. William Davenports where he lodges. He likewise propose teaching Gentlemen to FENCE in all its different branches, and will wait upon them by inquiring as above.2

22

[November 20, 1779]

MONSIEUR JEAN CADOU intends opening a DANCING SCHOOL, on Monday next, at the house of Mr. Cornelius De Forest, and will teach on Mondays and Tuesdays, for 50 dollars per month. He will also teach Ladies the FRENCH LANGUAGE, either at their own houses, or at the house of Mr. De Forest: Price the same as for dancing. Gentlemen may make application to him at Captain William Davenport's, in the back street.1

[November 20, 1779]

MONSIEUR DE CHEF DE BIEN, LIMNER IN MINATURE,
BEGS leave to inform the Ladies and Gentlemen, who are desirous of having their pictures drawn in miniature, that they will be waited upon, by addressing a line to him at Mr. William Davenports.2

Bucktrout, evidently, became a Tory during the last part of the Revolutionary War:

[November 24, 1781]

At the request of the Common Hall of this City, I am to inform your Excellency, that a number of Persons who were formerly residents of this Town, and who joined the British Army, have, since Lord Cornwallis' Reduction, returned here; and are at this time, quietly enjoying the privileges and advantages of good citizens which we cannot conceive they are entitled to. I have inclosed a List of such of them 23 as can be recollected at present, and have no doubt that some mode will be adopted by the Executive to enquire into this matter.
Jacob Williams
Joseph Thompson
Henry Drake Watson
Benj. Bucktrout
James Hubard jnr:
Wm. Hill
James Ross1

This is the only known account of Bucktrout's going off with Cornwallis. If Dr. Lyon Tyler is correct in assuming that Bucktrout had married a daughter of John Earnshaw, collector of the Upper ports of James River 1767-1775, then Bucktrout as a loyalist may have gone to England in 1779 to return with Cornwallis in 1781. Bucktrout may have been influenced by his father-in-law.2 Further reason to believe that Page's account is correct as to Bucktrout's Tory association, is that in the Public Record List appears the name of James Hubard who was from Williamsburg.

24

Williamsburg Land Tax records -- which include many lots in the James City part of Williamsburg -- list Benjamin Bucktrout as owner of only ¼ lot.1 This would seem to imply that Bucktrout had succeeded in selling the Francis Street property either in 1779 or sometime prior to 1782. Davenport's name does not appear in the tax records. This would indicate that he did not own lots in the city; however, some lot owners in the James City part of Williamsburg are not listed in the Land Tax records.

On the Frenchman's Map of Williamsburg (1782) there appears to be a very long house on this Lot with two outbuildings to the south.2 The plats of the city made ca. 1803 by Bucktrout,3 and the College Map (1791?)4 only add to the confusion. In spite of the fact that Bucktrout occupied the Chiswell house and apparently had the right to sell it in 1779, both of the plats referred to above put the name, "Chiswell" on three lots on Francis 25 Street and four to the south. Lot #9 marked "Chiswell or Robinson" seems to verify the connection between Chiswell's and John Robinson's property. No explanation can be found for so designating these lots as "Chiswell" unless the Chiswell estate held mortgage and Bucktrout never owned the property in fee simple.

It appears that James Southall, Williamsburg tavern keeper, had bought the lots designated by Bucktrout and others as "the Chiswell property." Williamsburg Land Tax records indicate that Southall held 6 ¼ lots in 1782 valued for tax purposes at £9.10.-.1 No record seems extant to show from whom Southall acquired the property. However, he seems to have held it until 1806 when Anthony Robinson acquired 6 ¼ lots via Moody [deputy sheriff who was, most probably trustee in the transaction].2

26

Robinson had been living in Williamsburg from ca. 1803.1 In 1809 his 6 ¼ lots were valued at $100 in the tax records. The same year he acquired 2 lots via Carter.2 Robinson was a lawyer. Apparently, he was not related to John Robinson. He married Elizabeth Russell, daughter of William Russell, clerk of James City County.

In 1815 Robinson sold his 8 ¼ lots in Williamsburg valued at $120 to John Bracken.3 A note stated that Bracken gained the property "Via Anthony Robinson and Elizabeth his Wife certain Houses & Lotts of Land."4

Bracken continued to own the property until his death in 1818 when it came into the ownership of his daughter, Mrs. Julia Bracken Avery.5 Mrs. Avery's husband 27 George Avery, was one of the operators and owners of the Dismal Swamp Land Company. We assume that she was living at Williamsburg during 1818-1835 when she died.1

A deed of date January 29, 1840 from Susan Byrd2 of Williamsburg to Lemuel J. Bowden3 of Williamsburg reveals the fact that Mrs. Byrd had bought the property from J. C. Avery:

[January 29, 1840]

[Susan Byrd of Williamsburg to Lemuel J. Bowden of the same city,
Consideration: $2000]

…has granted, bargained and so let and by these presents does grant, bargain and sell unto the said Lemuel J. Bowden, his heirs and assigns all that piece, parcel or lot of land lying, being and situate in the City of Williamsburg, on Francis Street, purchased by her of J. C. Avery, which piece of land contains by estimation five acres, more or less, together with the dwelling house and other buildings, stables, yards, gardens, hereditaments and appurtenances whatsoever, to the said piece or parcel of land...and the reversion and reversions, remainder and remainders, rents, issues and profits thereof. 28 The said piece or parcel of land and the houses thereto attached are the same lately occupied by George W. McCandlish, and purchased by Susan Byrd of Julia C. Avery, by deed dated on the ---- day of ---- and recorded in the Hustings Court office of the City of Williamsburg…
S. Byrd Seal1

[Recorded Williamsburg Hustings Court January 29, 1840]

Mrs. Byrd may have rented the property after 1828 as Mrs. Avery paid personal property taxes in the city from 1820 to 1828.2 Mrs. Byrd's daughter, Jane, married George W. McCandlish.3 McCandlish lived thereon until 1837 or later.4 In the session of 1839-1840 several college students boarded or roomed with McCandlish.5

In 1841 Bracken's estate sold the property to Lemuel J. Bowden according to the Williamsburg Land Tax 29 records.1 This seems to prove that though Mrs. Byrd, apparently, was the owner, obviously she never had gained the property in fee simple. When Bowden became owner, the property (lot & building) were assessed at $1555 with $1100 for buildings.2

From 1840 to 1861 (when the Williamsburg Land Tax records cease), Lemuel J. Bowden3 was owner.4

In December 1857, Lemuel J. Bowden insured his dwelling, furniture thus:

… On his Dwelling House in Williamsburg---$1800
On his Furniture therein -----------------5005

Because the court records for Williamsburg and James City county were destroyed in 1865 it is impossible to trace title until 1889 when James L. Slater acquired the property:

[November 20, 1889]

[Sydney Smith, special commissioner by decree of May 18, 1889, in Chancery Suit of Porter 30 and wife vs Bowden's Personal Representative,
to
James L. Slater]

…All that certain lot of land, in the City of Williamsburg, Virginia, fronting 130 feet on Francis Street and running back between parallel lines 96 feet, and bounded as follows: On the east by property of Delia A. Braithwaite, on the south by a portion of Bowden's lot, and on the west by the lot recently purchased by A. C. Peachy, being that portion of the Bowden lot known as and containing the 'Old Residence'1

In 1895 James L. Slater and Robinette, his wife, conveyed with general warranty, unto Richard A. Wise, the above described property:

[September 14, 1895]

[James L. Slater and wife
to
Richard A. Wise2]

…All that certain lot of land, with the buildings thereon, situate in the City of Williamsburg, County of James City, State of Virginia, fronting on Francis Street 130 feet, running south between parallel lines 525 feet, and bounded as follows: On the north by Francis Street, on the east by estate of W. W. Braithwaite, on the south by estate of said Braithwaite, and on the west by the lots of J. L. Slater and L. W. Wales….3

RR101704FREEMAN HOUSE (1929)
From negative made by Davidson (CWI Archives)

31

In April, 1922 Virginia Peachy Wise, heir of Richard A. Wise, conveyed to S. D. Freeman.1 Freeman gave deed of trust to B. D. Peachy to secure Virginia Peachy Wise the payment of $5000. This deed of trust: was released on April 3, 1928.2

There were many divisions of adjoining parcels of this property.

In 1928 Freeman and wife conveyed with general warranty, unto Dr. W. A. R. Goodwin, representing Colonial Williamsburg Restoration.3 It was leased to Freeman for five years.4

Several Williamsburg citizens recalled old Williamsburg around the period 1860-1865. Mr. John S. Charles referred to the property thus:

The long frame house now owned and occupied by Major Freeman, was standing in 1861, and although made longer, and otherwise improved, looks much as it did at that time. This 32 house was the home of Lemuel J. Bowden, before he built the house now owned by Judge Frank Armistead.1

Mrs. Victoria M. Lee described the property in this way:

Next to the Graves house was the old Bowden house, a large frame building, with Dutch colonial dormers. This house was much larger than it is today. At a later date a Mr. Slater bought this property and cut the house in two parts. The garden's around this house were very beautiful. Lem Bowden, at that time, had just built the large, brick house now owned by Judge Armistead. He moved there, and his mother moved into a tiny, frame, story and a half cottage on the back of the lot. She refused to live with her son because of his Union sympathies, as she was an ardent secessionist.2

For further details as to title, See: Accounting Department, Colonial Williamsburg, Incorporated.

Footnotes

^1. See: Illustration #3 for biographical data.
^1. Proof to follow chronologically in the report.
^2. York County records, Deeds V, p. 493.
^3. Jerdone Ledgers: Account Book (1750-1752) & (1750-1772) William and Mary College. See: Illustration #4 for complete copies.
^4. The Record of Bruton Parish Church (1941) p. 155.
^5. See: House History of the Deane House, Research Department.
^1. Illustration #4 for copies of work done for Col. Chiswell, Mrs. Chiswell and Speaker Robinson.
^2. Illustration #3 for biographical sketch.
^3. York County Records, Wills & Inventories, Book XX, p. 353.
^1. Virginia Gazette Purdie & Dixon, eds., July 18, 1766. Also: "Sketches and Reminiscences of the Dabney & Morris Families…" typescript, Research Department, Name Data: "Chiswell".
^2. Virginia Magazine of History, Vol. XVI, p. 207.
^1. Illustration #3 for obituary notice from Virginia Gazette.
^1. Hening's Statutes at Large …. vol. VIII, pp. 349-351.
^2. James City County Tax Lists (1768-1769), photostat Colonial Williamsburg from Virginia State Library.
^1. Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon, eds., June 2, 1768.
^1. Virginia Gazette, Rind, ed., December 28, 1769, p. 1, c. 1 & 2.
^2. In June, 1768 Peter Pelham, advertised "To be Sold by the subscriber, next door to Mrs. CHISWELL'S, A NEAT assortment of cutlery, consisting of knives, razors, scissors, &c… (Ibid., Rind, ed., June 16, 1768. See: House History of Pelham shop, Francis street, Research Dept.)
^1. Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon, eds., April 5, 1770.
^2. Illustration #4 for full account as taken from "Sales of the Robinson Estate" from EDMUND PENDLETON 1721-1803 a Biography, vol. I, appendix VI, pp. 384-385.
^3. Illustration #3 for biographical notes.
^1. To follow chronologically in the report. No fee simple deed has been found--possibly, it was under a mortgage.
^2. Ms Account Book of Edward Charlton, on loan to Research Department by Mrs. E. Lee Kirby. It is possible that Bucktrout may have been renting from the Chiswell-Robinson Estate and Holt was collecting rents in Williamsburg. How the account is cited in the Charlton Account Book is not known.
^Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon, eds., May 9, 1771.
^Ibid., Sept. 17, 1771.
^Ibid., July 7, 1774.
^1. Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon, eds., October 27, 1774.
^1. Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon [Dixon & Hunter], eds., February 4, 1775.
^2. Card under "Williamsburg History" Research Department.
^3. Calendar of Virginia State Papers, vol. VIII, p. 77.
^4. Ibid., p. 99.
^1. EDMUND PENDLETON 1721-1803 a Biography, by David John Mays (1952) vol. II, pp. 366-367.
^1. Lee Papers, American Phil. Society, copied by Keith Berwick, Research Department.
^1. THE PAPERS OF THOMAS JEFFERSON, vol. 1, (1760-1776) by Julian P. Boyd, ed., (1950), pp. 288-289.
^2. Southern Literary Messenger, vol. XXVII, p. 255, Copied from Lee Papers.
^1. See: Archaeological Report, Area H, July 30, 1941, Research Dept.: "Chiswell-Bucktrout House." See also: -- Illus. Report to Dr. E. M. Riley by Noël-Hume, March 30, 1959.
^1. Journal of the Council of the State of Virginia July 12, 1776-October 2, 1777, vol. I, pp. 352 & 452.
^2. Ibid., and Virginia Gazette, Purdie, ed., February 28, 1777.
^3. William and Mary Quarterly, series 1, vol. I, pp. 13-15.
^1. Journal of the Council of the State of Virginia October 6, 1777-November 30, 1781, vol. II, p. 244.
^2. Ibid., p. 251. (March 29, 1779).
^1. Virginia Gazette, Dixon & Nicholson, eds., August 28, 1779.
^2. Little could be found about William Davenport. His daughter, Elizabeth, married William Hunter — printer, in, December 1776. He is called "Captain" in a notice to follow in the report (Nov. 20, 1779). In a letter from Col. James Innes to Governor Jefferson, from "Williamsburg, April 20, 1781," there was an inclosure from William Davenport reporting that "Five Ships Five briggs three Sloops, four scouners, are now in my Sight …. The Botes one Brigg one Scouner are Standing up the River some of them as high as the point of Hog Island ... Wm Davenport." (The Papers of Thomas Jefferson, vol. V, pp. 504-505: Princeton, 1952). A William and Mary Davenport had five children baptized at Bruton Parish Church from 1757-1767. (The Record of Bruton Parish Church, pp. 149-152). In Virginia Militia for 1777: "Capt William Davenport was paid pr Accot [£]32.1.11." (Virginia Magazine of History, vol. 7, p. 420). In 1785, "Capt Wm Davenport (was allowed] 4000 A. December 3, 1785 for 3 yrs service." (Brumbough's Revolutionary War Records-Virginia, vol. I, p. 94.) In 1789, a William Davenport, lawyer, in Williamsburg, had repairs made to his house there. (Ledger C, p. 4, Humphrey Harwood, Colonial Williamsburg.)
^1. Virginia Gazette, Dixon & Nicolson, eds., October 2, 1779.
^2. Ibid., November 13, 1779.
^1. Virginia Gazette, Dixon & Nicolson, eds., November 20, 1779.
^2. Ibid.
^1. Calendar of Virginia State Papers, vol. II, p. 620 Letter J. Prentis to Governor Nelson.
^2. See: William and Mary Quarterly, series 1, vol. 5, p. 17 for Tyler's account; and American Loyalists Transcripts, Microfilm 73, CWI, for detailed account of John Earnshaw. In 1771 Earnshaw advertised for sale "at the Subscribers Dwellinghouse in Williamsburg SUNDRY kinds of HOUSEHOLD and KITCHEN FURNITURE…" (Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon, eds., March 21, 1771.) Bucktrout was a widower in 1797. See: Mrs. Peachy Wills letter to Mrs. Coalter in Research files, under Name Data. He married the second time Mary Bruce.
^1. Illustration #2 for details.
^3. Ibid.
^4. Tyler's adaptation of College Map opposite page 1.
^1. Williamsburg Land Tax Records, originals Virginia State Archives; microfilm Colonial Williamsburg. See: Illustration #2 for complete records.
^2. Philip Moody owned only 3 ¼ lots (all accounted for) and as he was deputy sheriff at the time, it may be that he was having a forced sale or the Chiswell-John Robinson estate which had not been entirely settled or of Bucktrout's interest in it. As there are no deeds to this property extant, it is not possible to clear this point entirely. However, an insurance policy for 1806 giving the Ewing estate, described it as "between the Lotts of Josias Moody on the West and the Lott of Anthony Robinson on the East in the county of James City." (See: Mutual Assurance Society policy, Colonial Williamsburg.)
^1. Illustration #3 for biographical sketch.
^3. Illustration #3 for biographical sketch.
^5. The property continued to be listed as "John Bracken's Estate" in the tax records but subsequent sources indicate that Mrs. Avery was his heir and sold it. Data to follow in report. .
^1. Southall Papers, Legal Estates, James City County, folder 124, William and Mary College. Southall stated that Mrs. Avery died in 1835.
^2. Illustration #2 for copy from records. Mrs. Susan Byrd was the widow of Addison Byrd, a lawyer, and a son of William Byrd IV.
^3. Illustration #3 for biographical sketch.
^1. Mss Colonial Williamsburg Archives.
^2. Williamsburg Personal Property Tax records, photostat, Colonial Williamsburg.
^3. William and Mary Quarterly, series 1, Vol. 9. p. 263.
^4. Mutual Assurance Society, Policy #8586, microfilm Colonial Williamsburg. Lucius Cary, owner of property to the west, describes his houses as "situated between McCandlish's lands and Ebenezer Ewing's estate."
^5. William and Mary Quarterly, series 2, Vol. 4, pp. 62-63.
^2. Ibid.
^3. Illustration #3 for biographical sketch.
^4. Illustration #2 for tax accounts against the property.
^5. Southern Protection Insurance Company, policy #5052, MS Colonial Williamsburg Archives.
^1. Williamsburg and the County of James City, Deed Book #2, pp. 315-316.
^2. Illustration #3 for biographical notes.
^3. James City County and the City of Williamsburg, Deed Book #3, p. 280.
^1. Ibid., Deed Book #9, pp. 354-355.
^2. Ibid., pp. 355-357.
^3. See: Chain to title, Accounting Department, Colonial Williamsburg, Inc. for details.
^4. Williamsburg and James City County court records, Deed Book #12, pp. 392-394.
^1. "Recollections of Williamsburg" (1933) typescript, Research Department, p. 57.
^2. "Williamsburg in 1861" by Victoria M. Lee (1933), p. 70.
33

Illustration #1

RR101706From Frenchman's Map 1782?

34

RR101707[Bucktrout Map 1803]

35

RR101705Archaeological Drawings made by J. M. Knight, July 26, 1941, Area H.

36

Illustration #2

Williamsburg Land Tax Records
1782James Southall6 ¼ lots £ 9.10
1783Same
1784Same
1785Same
1786James Southall6 ¼ lots£14
1787Same
1788James Southall6 ¼ lots£50
1789James Southall6 ¼ lots£33
1790Same
1791Same
1792Same
1794James Southall6 ¼ lots£75
1795Same
1796Same
1797Same
1798James Southall6 ¼ lots$150
1799Same
1800James Southall6 ¼ lots$150
1801Same
1802Illegible
1803James Southall6 ¼ lots$100
1 lot$100
1804James Southall Estate7 ¼ lots$200
1805Same
1806James Southall est1 lots$100
Anthony Robinson6 ¼ lots$100via Moody
1807James Southall Est1 lots$200
Anthony Robinson6 ¼ lots$100
1809James Southall Est1 lots$200
Anthony Robinson6 ¼ lots$110
1810-1814Same for both
1815John Bracken8 ¼ lots$120Via Anthony Robinson and Elizabeth, his wife
James Southall est1 lot$200
1816-1817Same for Southall
37
1818William McCandlish1 lot$200Formerly charged to James Southall's Estate
John Bracken7 ¼ lots
1820John Bracken's Est$1000 bldgs $1275 lot & bldgs.
1830John Bracken's Est$1275 lot & bldgs; $1000 bldgs.
1835John Bracken's Est$1275 lot & bldgs; $1000 bldgs.
1838John Bracken's est $1275 lot & bldgs; $1000 bldgs.
1840John Bracken's est$1555 lot & bldgs; $1100 bldgs.
1841Lemuel Bowden$1500 lots & bldgs; $1100Via Susan Byrd Heretofore charged to the estate of John Bracken, decd.
1847Lemuel J. Bowden $1500 lot & bldgs; $1100 bldgs.via Susan Byrd
1850Lemuel J. Bowden$1500 lot & bldgs; $1100 bldgs.
1851Lemuel J. Bowden$1800 lot & bldgs; $1200 bldgs.
1854Lemuel J. Bowden$1800 lot & bldgs; $1200 bldgs.
1857Lemuel J. Bowden$1800 lot & bldgs; $1200 bldgs.
1858Lemuel J. Bowden$3000 lot & bldgs; $2000
300(New house assessed by the Commissioners)
1860Lemuel J. Bowden$6000 lot & bldgs; $5500 bldgs.
1861Lemuel J. Bowden$6000 lot & bldgs; $5500 bldgs.

[1859-1861 tax rates above refer to Bowden's house and lot on Duke of Gloucester Street which he built about this time.]

38

Illustration #3

Lemuel J. Bowden

Lemuel Jackson Bowen was the son of William and Mildred Davis Bowden of James City county, Virginia. In 1830-31 he was a student at William and Mary College. In 1833 he obtained a license to practice law in Virginia. In 1840 he purchased the house and lot known as the "Chiswell-Bucktrout House" for $2000. He lived in and retained the property until ca. 1861. In 1856 he bought from the trustees of Bruton Parish Church a lot which lay southwest of the Church. He built a "splendid ediface of brick on this lot."

Bowden was a member of the state legislature for three terms, a member of the Virginia Constitutional Conventions of 1849 and 1851; in 1861 he was a presidential elector. Elected to the United States senate by the so-called Virginia legislature held in Alexandria following the Civil War, he served from March 3, 1863 until his death in Washington City, January 2, 1864.

While mayor of Williamsburg in May, 1862 he was called "a traitor" by the citizens. A band serenaded Mayor Bowden on May 14th. There was loud cheer and calls of "Down with the traitor! If we ever recover our power…"

Both Lemuel Bowden and his brother Henry Moseley Bowden, were strong in their devotion to the Union cause, and sooner than abandon their convictions, they removed from Williamsburg during the Civil War. Henry went to Norfolk where he was clerk of the circuit court there and Lemuel took up his residence in Washington.

Sources used in compiling these notes:

  • Tyler's Virginia Biography, vols. III & IV, pp. 103, 416-417 respectively.
  • Armistead Papers, William and Mary College Archives.
  • Armistead House History, Research Department.
  • Chiswell-Bucktrout House History, Research Department.
  • Southall Papers, William and Mary College Archives.
  • A Provisional List of William and Mary Students (Richmond:1941)

39

THE REVEREND JOHN BRACKEN

John Bracken was born in England in 1745 and died in Williamsburg in 1818. he appears in Virginia church history in July, 1772 when he was "Licensed for Va. For Amelia County." In 1773 he was chosen rector of Bruton Parish, and in 1776 he married Miss Sally Burwell, daughter of Carter of "Carters Grove," deceased. The marriage was announced in the Virginia Gazette thus:

"Rev. John Bracken, Rector of Bruton Parish, to Miss Sally Burwell, daughter of the late Carter Burwell, Esq., of Carters Grove."

Three children were born of this marriage: John, born 1779, Julia Carter born 1781 and Sarah born 1785. All of these births were recorded in Bruton Parish Register. Julia married George Avery. She lived in Williamsburg in 1819-1827. Sarah married John Butler in July, 1809. (Letter of St. G. Tucker to Joseph Cabell, July 21, 1809 (Alderman Lib., films #7; M-62-7, CWI)

In 1777 Bracken was occupying the handsome brick house on Francis Street still known now as the "Allen-Byrd House." He rented this house from Mrs. Mary Willing Byrd, executrix of William Byrd III, the former owner. As Master of the Grammar School and Librarian ca. 1777 to 1779 — when the Grammar School was abolished along with his professorship of Humanity — he, apparently, occupied the Francis Street property. In 1780, 1782, and 1783 Bracken was paid by Humphrey Harwood, local carpenter and builder, for teaching the Harwood boys. In 1784 he advertised in the Virginia Gazette and Weekly Advertiser, Richmond, that he was undertaking "the tuition of five or six boys, who may also live with him. As his attention will be entirely confined to so small a number, the terms for board and tuition will be forty guineas per ann." The same year, Bracken paid Byrd's estate £46.16.0 "for rents."

In 1786 Bracken became owner of the former Byrd House and lots in Williamsburg.

In 1787 the Grammar School was held in the Capitol with Bracken as head master. This year he brought suit against William and Mary College to recover his lost professorship and also for back pay which he claimed he should have received following the abolition of the Grammar School in 1779. In 1792 he was reinstated at the college; in 1793 he received the degree of Doctor of Divinity from the College. In 1800 Bracken was named mayor of Williamsburg. In 1812 he was selected as President of William and Mary College. He held this office until 1814. From 1801-1818 Bracken was one of the managers of the Dismal Swamp Land Company.

In 1815 Bracken bought the property known as the "Chiswell-Bucktrout House" and held it until his death when his heirs became owners.

In July, 1818 he died. A Richmond newspaper stated that he died on July 15th and a Norfolk paper stated that he died on July 16th. Both state that he was buried at Carters Grove. No marker has survived if there was ever one to his memory. On July 30, 1818 Robert Saunders of Williamsburg wrote to Joseph Prentis, Suffolk, "Our old pastor too, Mr Bracken has passed to the world of Spirits-tranquil and resigned as Job."

40

Sources used in compiling these notes:

  • Historical Magazine of the Protestant Episcopal Church, vol. 10 (1941), pp. 354-389, contains as article by Rutherfoord Goodwin, entitled "The Revered John Bracken (1745-1818)."
  • The Virginia Gazette and Weekly Advertiser, (Richmond, Nicolson & Prentis, eds.), October 30, 1784.
  • Richmond Enquirer, July 24, 1818.
  • American Beacon, Norfolk, July 22, 1818
  • Virginia Gazette (Dixon [& Hunter], ed.) September 21, 1776.
  • William & Mary College Notes, compiled by Mary M. Goodwin, Research Department, CWI.
  • Virginia State Library: U.S. Circuit Court, Va. Dist., Ended Cases "Murdock & Co. vs. William Byrd's Extx, 1797. Acct Estate of Colo Byrd with Mary Byrd Executrix made September 29th 1790."
  • Dismal Swamp Land Co. Papers, M-36-3, CWI
  • Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon, eds., June 17, 1773.
  • Ibid., Purdie, ed., September 13, 1776.
  • Ibid., (other items in this paper).
  • Swem's Virginia Historical Index.
  • Tyler's Virginia Biography, vol. I.

For further data on Bracken in Williamsburg consult House Histories of Allen-Byrd House, Bracken House, and Chiswell-Bucktrout House, Williamsburg.

41

BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT

Benjamin Bucktrout,1 cabinet maker, came to Williamsburg from London in 1766, and opened a shop on Duke of Gloucester Street, near the Capitol. He first gave notice of this fact in the Virginia Gazette for July 25, 1766:

"B. BUCKTROUT, CABINET MAKER, from LONDON, on the main street near the Capitol in Williamsburg, makes all sorts of cabinet work, either plain or ornamental, in the neatest and newest fasions. He hopes to give satisfaction to all Gentlemen who shall please to favor him with their commands.
N.B. Where likewise may be had the mathematical GOUTY CHAIR."[Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon, eds.]

In 1767, Anthony Hay, who had been a cabinet maker in Williamsburg for some years, turned over his shop and his customers to Benjamin Bucktrout. Hay purchased the Raleigh Tavern at that time, and was the successful and popular keeper of that tavern until his death in 1770. He leased his shop to Bucktrout (the shop stood on Nicholson Street, on lot #263 or #264 — both of which Hay owned), and both Hay and Bucktrout announced the change in their situations in the same issue of the Gazette:

"Williamsburg, Jan. 6, 1767
"THE Gentlemen who have bespoke WORK of the subscriber may depend upon having it made in the best manner by Mr. BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT, to whom he has given up his business. — I return the Gentlemen who have favoured me with their custom many thanks, and am
Their most humble servant,
ANTHONY HAY."
"Williamsburg, Jan. 6, 1767
"Mr. ANTHONY HAY having lately removed to the RAWLEIGH tavern, the subscriber has taken his shop, where the business will be carried on in all its branches. He hopes that those Gentlemen who were Mr. Hay's customers will favour him with their orders, which shall be executed in the best and most expedious manner. He likewise makes all sorts of Chinese 42 and Gothick PALING for gardens and summer houses.
N.B. SPINETS and HARPSICORDS made and repaired.
BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT."[Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon, January 8, 1767.]

For a time Bucktrout had a partner1 — although the first record we have found of that fact appears in an advertisement announcing the dissolution of the partnership:

"Williamsburg, March 1, 1769
"The partnership between Bucktrout and Kennedy, though not yet dissolved, will terminate as soon as the work which is already bespoke can be finished, and matter brought to a proper settlement; at which time WILLIAM KENNEDY Proposes carrying on the business of cabinet making, at the house where Mr. Pelham now lives. Any of those Gentlemen who have been customers to Bucktrout and Kennedy; and all others who please to employ him, may rely on his best endeavours to give satisfaction.
"He has no intention to rob Mr. Bucktrout of his old customers, nor does he think he can as yet properly call any his own.[Ibid., March 9, 1769.]

In the fall of 1769, Bucktrout advertised for "JOURNEYMAN CABINET MAKERS, who, if they understand their business, will meet with good encouragement."(Ibid., September 7, 1769.) In 1771, he offered a reward for a runaway apprentice — "an Apprentice Lad about twenty years of Age…and a cabinet maker by trade."[Ibid., April 11, 1771.]

Bucktrout evidently moved from Anthony Hay's shop ca. 1770; for on January 3, 1771 Edmund Dickinson, also a cabinet maker, announced that he had "lately opened the Shop" formerly belonging to Mr. Anthony Hay. [Ibid., Jan. 3, 1771.] It is not known whether Bucktrout moved to the house on Francis Street, formerly the property of Col. John Chiswell, at this time, or later. His advertisements in 1774 noted that he was then on Francis Street; and in 1779 he offered for sale the house in which he lived "formerly belonging to Colonel Chiswell." It is very possible that he moved onto this property after leaving Hay's Shop, but we have found no record of his purchase of the property.

At any rate, from 1771 on, Bucktrout's business grew to include paper hanging, and the sale of a large assortment of imported merchandise.2 The following advertisements indicate the range of his business for the next several years:

"May 9, 1771
"Just IMPORTED, and to be SOLD cheap for ready Money, by the Subscriber, in WILLIAMSBURG,
43 "A NEAT ASSORTMENT of PAPER HANGINGS,
of various kinds, and of the newest Fashions, for Staircases, Rooms, and Ceilings; namely, embossed, stucco, Chintz, striped, Mosaick, Damask, and common — *** Rooms papered in the neatest Manner, and on reasonable Terms.
BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT."[Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon, eds.]
"Sept. 17, 1771.
"To Be SOLD, any Time betwixt this and October Court, for ready money, SUNDRY fine PRINTS done by Mr. FRY, and some ELECTIONS PIECES by Hogarth, the Property of a Gentleman gone to England. They may be seen at any Time on applying to
BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT.
"N.B. Sundry neat PAPER HANGINGS to be sold. Rooms neatly papered on reasonable terms."[Ibid., September 17, 1771.]
"Williamsburg, July 4, 1774.
"I HAVE for Sale, for ready Money, the following Articles, viz. MATRASSES, made of best English curled Hair, without any Addition of Tow or Wool; HAIR SEATING for Chairs; BOXES of TYPES for marking Linens, Books, &c. PAPER HANGINGS, of the best Kinds, and most fashionable patterms. I have likewise to dispose of, the Remainder of the Time of an indented young woman from Ireland, who was bred up as a Spinner in one of the first Linen Manufactures in that Kingdom; and the sole Reason of my parting with he is my not having Employ for her,… BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT."[Ibid., July 7, 1774.]
"October 27, 1774
"Just Imported, and to be SOLD cheap for ready Money, by the Subscriber in Francis Street, Williamsburg,
"FINE bottled Porter, Taunton Beer, Gloucester Cheese, Negro Plains, Kendal Cottons, Plain and Striped Blankets, Fine Lustrings of different patterns, Yorkshire Cloths, Pattern for Mens Surtout Coats, with Trimmings to each, Mans fine and coarse Hats, Velvet bound hats with Roses, Mens Boots, Womens and Childrens Leather Shoes, Mens Gloves, Womens fine French Kid Gloves, Guns, Silver mounted and plain Pistols, Saddles complete, Whips, Hair Broms and Brushes, Wool and Playing Cards, Horn Lanthorns, Plaistering Trowels, Sets of Types for marking of Linen, Checks and Striped Holland, Pepper, Allspice, Giner, Paper Hangings for Rooms, Best Durham Mustard, Blue and White Water Jugs, Chamber Pots, Quart and Pint Mugs, Milk Pans, Sage and Balm Tea Pots, Coffin Furniture, Hair Seating for Chairs, Matrasses, Glass Salts, Vinegar Cruits, Salt, &c. &c.
BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT."
[Ibid., October 27, 1774.] 44
"February 4, 1775.
BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT
CABINET MAKER, IN FRANCIS STREET, WILLIAMSBURG,
STILL carries on that Business in all its Branches, where Ladies and Gentlemen may be supplied with any Sort of Cabinet Work in the best and neatest Manner… I return those Ladies and gentlemen who were pleased to favour me with their Commands my most grateful Thanks, and hope for a Continuance of their Favours, which to merit shall always be the Study of their most humble Servant.
BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT
"N.B. I should be glad to take one or two apprentices, of bright Genuises, and of good Dispositions, and such whose Friends are willing to find them Clothes."
[Ibid., Dixon & Hunter, February 4, 1775.]

In August, 1779, Bucktrout offered for sale the house which formerly belonged to Colonel Chiswell, on Francis Street, as well as some of his household furniture and furnishings, his cabinet-makers tools, and some seasoned wood for cabinet-making and buildings:

"To be sold betwixt this and the 27th of September, at private sale; the houses and lots here the subscriber lives, formerly belonging to Colonel Chiswell, it is very well calculated for a tavern as there is ever necessary requisite, with a very good pasture joining. Also will be sold for ready money, on Wednesday the 22d of September, a variety of household and kitchen furniture, consisting of beds, bedding, mahogany chairs, tables, and chest of drawers, handsome looking-glasses, Queen's china plates and dishes, ivory handled knives and forks, and an easy chair. Likewise two riding chairs and harness, two carts with harness for four horses, three very good milch cows, thee good chair horses, two mare colts,… a Negro woman, who is an exceeding good washer and ironer; likewise will be sold a chest of cabinet makers and house joiners tools, with a quantity of very fine broad one, two and three inch mahogany plank, which has been out this five years, a parcel of shingles, pine and oak plank and scantling, nails of different sizes, window glass 8 by 10, and many other articles. *** All persons indebted to the subscriber are desired to settle their accounts by the last of September; and those who have accounts are desired to apply for payment. …I intend leaving this state in October next. BENJAMIN BUCKTROUT"
[Ibid., Dixon and Nicolson, eds., August 28, 1779.]

During the early years of the Revolution, from ca. 1777 until 1779, Bucktrout was purveyor of the Public Hospitals. On November 19, 1778, the Council of State decided that "he ought to be allowed in the future for his Services as Purveyor and Steward to the public Hospital four dollars & one ration per diem."(Council Journals, II, 219.) Prior to that date, he had received various sums for his services. He resigned in 1779, and on march 29th of that year Thomas Russell was appointed Purveyor in his place.

45

We do not know whether or not Bucktrout left the state in October of 1779 — the date mentioned when he offered his house etc. for sale. He certainly gave up the house, for on the 2nd of October, 1779, William Davenport announced that he was opening Tavern "in the house formerly occupied by Col. Chiswell, and lately by Benjamin Bucktrout."[Virginia Gazette, Dixon & Nicolson, eds. Oct. 2, 1779.]

He continued to own property in Williamsburg, and if he left, had returned there prior to 1784. For in that year he gave notice that he intended "for England shortly, and shall not return until next summer."[Virginia Gazette & Weekly Advertiser, July 17, 1784.] In 1788 he again announced that he intended to go "to England immediately."[Ibid., August 14, 1788.]

The Williamsburg Land Tax Records, which begin in 1782, list Benjamin Bucktrout as owner of ¼ lot in 1782. In 1812 he owned 8 ¼ lots. In 1813 the tax on his real estate was charged to his "Estate" — indicating that he had died between the date of the tax record in 1812 and 1813.

In 1814 his property was charged to his wife, Mary Bucktrout, as "devise." [Williamsburg Land Tax records, 1782-1865.]

February 8, 1951
Mary Goodwin

46

Mrs. Peachy Wills, an aunt of Robert Greenhow, merchant of Williamsburg, in a letter to Mrs. John Colter, Staunton, on April 30, 1797 had some gossipy remarks about old Mr. Bucktrout:

…what think you of the widower Bucktrout, he is proving his title to both parts of his Name, pitty it was not budgeon instead of trout as to the first part, he is turn'd out quite a beau, scarlet waistcoat and his neat wig in a stiff single curl round and mounted on good horse with a servant riding behind him on a good one also, following a chair in which the damsel was going out of Town, and this not once or twice but as often as this Miss Bruce goes to see her sister in the country, who married a young Mr Brown a grandson of old Weldons, I can but think if old Molly could make him see her looking at him how he'd jump out of his Scarlet attire and shrink into his old greasy leather indispensibles an white cap again, it really is ridiculously laughable to see the old puppy apeing, what he never was, I mean smart cleverness, he prances after the poor girl, incessantly, people say, and 'tis supposed, she will be brought to consider that half a loaf is better than no bread, poor girl I sincerely pity her if she is under undue influence, his other part of Name comes under that of fish which may be hooked, or [torn] netted, or snarled, which of these traps she made use off [sic] know not, but tis certain she plays him about her will at present,…(Typescript copy of letter supposed to be in the Tucker-Coleman Collection. Mrs. Coleman seems to think the original was at the College. Not able to locate the original letter. See: Name Data card, Research Department)

Bucktrout's first wife's name judging from reference above must have been Mollywidow Mary Martin DB. If Dr. Tyler is correct, she was Mary Earnshaw, daughter of John Earnshaw, collector of the upper port of James River until his exit to England in 1775 when he became a Tory. (See: William and Mary Quarterly, series 1, vol 5, p. 17; and Microfilm M-73 Loyalists Transcripts, CWI) Earnshaw's personal property in York county was sold for escheated property in 1779. (Virginia Gazette, June 8, 1779)

The marriage bond between Benjamin Bucktrout and Mary Bruce is recorded in York County marriage bonds, microfilm, Research Department, as July 3, 1797.

47

COLONEL JOHN CHISWELL

Colonel John Chiswell of Hanover County, Virginia married Elizabeth Randolph, daughter of Colonel William and Elizabeth Beverley Randolph. She was born on October 14, 1715; married Colonel Chiswell on May 19, 1736 and died February, 1776 at the home of her daughter in Caroline County.

Colonel Chiswell was the son of Charles Chiswell (1677-1737) who was Clerk of the General Court. John Chiswell was a metallurgist, member of the House of Burgesses from Hanover 1742-1755 and from Williamsburg 1756-1758. At one time he lived at "Scotchtown" in Hanover County. In Williamsburg he lived in the house now known as the "Chiswell-Bucktrout" on Francis Street.

Children of Colonel Chiswell and his wife Elizabeth, were: Elizabeth, born May 24, 1737; married Speaker John Robinson (his third wife) in December, 1759; Mary, born 1739 February 22nd, married Warner Lewis Jr. in 1768; and Lucy, born August 3, 1752, married Colonel William Nelson of Hanover County on November 24, 1770.

William Byrd, John Chiswell and his son-in-law, John Robinson, owned lead mines in Wythe and Montgomery County, Virginia. Upon the death of Chiswell in 1766, and of Robinson the same year, it was found that the mines were financially involved almost to the point of insolvency.

Colonel Chiswell was part-owner of the Raleigh Tavern. In 1752 he and George Gilmer bought the Tavern. Prior to 1761 Chiswell had owned Lots 329-332 on Palace Street.

In 1766 while in a tavern in Cumberland County, John Chiswell quarreled with a Scotch merchant, Robert Routledge, and called him "a fugitive revel, a villain who came to Virginia to cheat and defraud men of their property, and a Presbyterian fellow…" Chiswell killed Routledge, was arrested, and was let out of jail on bail by three friends who were judges of the General Court. Before the time for trial, Chiswell died — some said by his own hand. Chiswell died in Williamsburg on October 15, 1766, at his house on Francis Street.

Mrs. Chiswell was living at the Chiswell house in Williamsburg in 1770 when it was sold. She died in March, 1776, at the home of her daughter Mrs. William Nelson, in Caroline county, in her 54th year. William Nelson was executor of her estate.

Sources used in compiling these notes:

  • York County records, Deed Book 6, pp. 364-366 (August 11, 1761). Deeds V, p. 493 (August 17, 1752). Deeds 6, p. 506 (May 2, 1763).
  • The Beverly Family of Virginia, by John McGill (Columbia, S.C. 1956) p.118. 48
  • Virginia Magazine of History, vol. III, pp. 263-264; vol. XVI, p. 207.
  • Journals of the House of Burgesses 1742-47, 1748-49, 1752-55, 1756-1758.
  • Mays, David: Edmund Pendleton 1721-1803 A Biography, vol. I, appendix VI, pp. 384-385 (Harvard Press, 1952).
  • Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon, eds., Oct. 17, 1766.
  • Virginia Gazette, Purdie, ed., March 8, 1776.
  • Campbell's Colonial Caroline (Richmond: 1954) p. 485.

49

ANTHONY ROBINSON

Anthony Robinson, son of Anthony V of York County was born in 1770. He married Elizabeth Rusell, daughter of William Russell, clerk of James City county court. He died in Richmond in 1851.

Anthony Robinson moved to Richmond in 1785. About 1797 he moved to Williamsburg as assistant in the office of William Russell. In 1799 he married Russell's daughter and returned to Richmond where he became assistant to William Wirt, the clerk of the House of Delegates. In 1802-3 he returned to live in Williamsburg where he remained until 1814 when he returned to Richmond in the office of Auditor of Public Accounts and later as discount clerk in the Bank of Virginia. In 1850 he became Agent for Pension for the state.

In 1806 he bought 6 ¼ lots valued at $100 via Moody of Williamsburg. From subsequent records we know that these were the lots known as the "Chiswell-Bucktrout" property. In 1815 he conveyed to John Bracken according to the Land Tax Records.

Mrs. Robinson was the niece of Mrs. Jane Hunter Charlton and Margaret Hunter.

Mrs. Robinson's sister, Jane, married Michael B. Poitiaux.

50

JOHN ROBINSON

Robinson, John, son of John Robinson, president of the council, was born February 3, 1704. He studied at William and Mary College, and after graduation was probably for many years the most influential man in Virginia. He resided in King and Queen county upon the Mattaponi river where his residence was known as "Mt Pleasant." He was a member of the house of burgesses for King and Queen county from 1736 to 1765 and speaker of the house from 1738 to 1765, and treasurer during the same period. As a presiding officer he was compared to Richard Onslow, speaker of the house of commons. As treasurer he ably administered the financial affairs of the colony, but was to free in lending out the colony's money. On his death in 1765/66 it was found that he owed the public £100,761 7s. 5d. It seems certain, however, that he expected to return this sum from the payments of the creditors or from his own estate. In the end this was indeed done and the public suffered no loss. He died May 11, 1766. He married three times (first) Mary Storey, (second) Lucy Moore and (third) Susanna Chiswell, daughter of Colonel Chiswell, of Williamsburg. His only known descendants are those by his daughter Susan of the last marriage, who married Robert Nelson, of "Malvern Hill."

On Saturday night last, the Honourable JOHN ROBINSON, Esq; in the 63d Year of his Age, Speaker to the Honourable House of Burgesses, and Treasurer of this Colony, paid the last Debt to Nature, after labouring some Days with the most excruciating, Torments of the Stone, which he bore with that Christian Fortitude and Resignation to the Divine Will, which had ever dignified his Actions. To say only that he was a good Man, would not be doing Justice to his Excellence; for he was an affectionate Husband, a tender Father, and an universal Friend to Mankind. In a Word, his Soul was animated with every social Virtue, which, from every honest heart, must draw a Tear of Sympathy to the Memory of such a worthy Member of Society.

Sources used in compiling these notes:

  • Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon, eds., May 16, 1766 (Robinson's Death)
  • D.J. Mays, Edmund Pendleton (1721-1803), vols I & II (Cambridge, 1952)
  • Virginia Magazine of History, vol XXXVXI, pp. 201, 210 (portrait)
  • Ibid., vol XXXV, p. 42 Vestryman Stratton Major Parish
  • Charles Campbell's History…of Virginia (Phila 1860) p. 548 (burial place)
  • Bishop William Meade's Old Churches & Families, vol I, p. 378 (epitaph on tomb at Mount Pleasant)
  • Tyler's Virginia Biography, I, p. 315.

51

JAMES BARRETT SOUTHALL
(1726-1801)

James Barrett Southall was the son of Dasey and Edith Southall. He was born in October, 1726. he married Frances [Jerdone? Or Jones?] and had these children: John, born 1763; James who was a Major and Captain in 1781-1782; William, commander of the Williamsburg militia in 1780; Frances who married John Daingerfield; Elizabeth who married Peter Randolph of "Chatsworth"; Ann who married Thomas Mutter; George who never married and Peyton who married Helen M. Macauly of Yorktown. She married after Southall's death, Robert Anderson of Williamsburg.

James Barrett Southall was a tavern keeper in Williamsburg many years. He rented Mr. Weatherburn's tavern from ca. 1767 to 1771 when he went to the Raleigh Tavern. He was owner of 6 ¼ lots on Frances Street from ca. 1782 to his death. These lots were known as "the Chiswell property."

Southall insured the Raleigh Tavern in 1896 at $2150. In 1797 he advertised the Tavern for rent stating that "as a public house, it is inferior to none in the place."

Southall died in 1801 in Williamsburg.

SOURCES:

  • Armistead Papers 1736-1897 (61), William & Mary Archives, folder 3.
  • William and Mary Quarterly, series 1, vol. 12, pp. 29-30.
  • The Beverly Family of Virginia, p. 182.
  • Tyler's Quarterly Magazine, vol. 8, p. 133.
  • Owalthmay's Historical Register of Virginians in the Revolution, pp. 728-729.
  • Mutual Assurance Society Policy (1796), original Virginia State Archives; copy Colonial Williamsburg.
  • The Virginia Gazette and General Advertiser (Richmond) Sept. 20, 1797.
  • Williamsburg Land Tax records, Virginia State Library; copy Colonial Williamsburg.
  • James City County Land and Personal Property Tax Records, Virginia State Library, copy Colonial Williamsburg.
  • Notes on Raleigh Tavern, Research Department.

52

DR. RICHARD ALSOP WISE

Dr. Richard Alsop Wise, born in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, September 2, 1843, was the son of Gov. Henry A. Wise of Virginia. He attended private schools in Richmond, Dr. Gessner Harrison's university school, and William and Mary College for two years. He served in the Confederate army as a private in Stuart's cavalry and as assistant inspector-general of Wise's brigade. He was graduated from the Medical College of Virginia in 1867 and practiced afterwards. From 1869-1880 he was professor at William and Mary College; superintendent of the Eastern Lunatic Asylum 1882-1884; member of the state legislature 1885-1887; clerk of the circuit and county courts of Williamsburg 1887-1893; Republication congressman 1898-1900. Dr. Wise died on December 21, 1901 at Williamsburg, his home.

Henry A. Wise and Virginia P. Wise, children of Dr. Wise, inherited the property on Francis Street, Williamsburg. Henry A. Wise died ca. 1915. Virginia P. Wise sold the property in 1922 to S.D. Freeman, who in 1928 conveyed to W.A.R. Goodwin, acting for the Williamsburg Restoration.

Sources used in compiling these notes:

  • Tyler, Lyon G., Encyclopedia of Virginia Biography, vol. III, p. 134 (N.Y. 1915)

53

Illustration #4

JERDONE PAPERS 1750-1752
William and Mary College Archives
M-152-1 (CWI)
YORKTOWN ACCOUNT BOOK
1751 Dec 16thCol. John ChiswellDr
6 pewter dishes£1.10. -
2 dos 6 hard mettle pewter plates3. -. -
1 damask Table Cloth 7/4-.13. -
1 ditto 8/4-.14. 6
1 ditto ¼2.10. -
£8. 7. 6
1752 May 16th
Col. John ChiswellDr
2 casks nails
25 M 6
25 M 6
pork£18. 4. 6
1751 June 27Col. John ChiswellDr
To 11 yards Crape 4/6£2. 9. 6
To 3 yds black Allamode 3/9 .11. 3
¾ yds Buckram 1 ½ yds Irish Linen-. 6. 3
2 sticks twist 7/ ½ 3 bank silk-. 3. 6
1 ps house garters 2/ 3 banks silk 9/ . 3. 3
11 Coat Buttons 1/3 & 4 ½ Jacks1.10. ½
1 ½ Ell Osrabgg1.10. ½
JERDONE PAPERS (W&M) 1750-1772
M-152-2 (CWI)
p. 71John Chiswell & Company of Wmsburg bal fo: 53----£16.16.2
p. 87 1753Chiswell & Gilmer in Wmsburg
AplTo Rum Acct pr Journal Fo 84----------£20.13. 0
p. 99Col. John Chiswell of WilliamsburgDr
1754 Octr 24[settlement by Chiswell for Buchanan & Hamilton£773. 4. 3]
54 Alexr Craig Account Book (1761-1766)
Colonial Williamsburg Archives
*1761 May
Col. Chiswell
To 9 feet 6 Reins-. 8. -
June 26
Colo Chiswell to be pd by the Speaker
To Coupling Reins, 2 wooden girths & 1 Brass Screw Rung for chair harnass -. 9. -
July 8
Colo Chiswell
To buckles & straps to a Trunk-. 1. 1/3
To Stirrups
To Cruper Loop & 3 girths Straps-. 1. 3
Oct -
Colo Chiswell
To a Strap to a Horse for Coach harness-. 1. -
Nov. 18
Mr Speaker
To a Susingle & Double girths-. 5. -
To mails straps for Mrs. Chiswell-. 1. 6
Dec. 30
Colo Chiswell
To mendg Chariot Braces-.10.-
1762
Jan 8
Colo Chiswell
To 1 pr of Pale pieces, 1 pr of Side Braces & Mendg 2 Traces1. 2. -
1763
May 3
The Speaker
To mendg harnass for Mrs. Chiswell-. 2. 6
55 EDMUND PENDLETON 1721-1803 A Biogrpahy, by David Mays (Harvard Press, 1956)
Vol. I, Appendix VI, pp. 384-385:
"SALES OF THE ROBINSON ESTATE
Sales of the Estate of John Robinson Esqr.
Times of SalePlace of SaleLands had of ChiswellOther LandsSlaves
1767
1770
AprilWilliamsburg[£]480[£]533[£]843.11.0
Other PersonalsTotals
[£] 598,0,5[£]2454.11.5"
pp. 201-202, f.n. 134, [Notes list of sales as given in "Lidderdale vs Robinsons admrs" (Ended Files 136 & 137, U.S. Dist. Ct. Richmond, or U.S. Circuit Ct. Rec. Book 20, pp. 274-464.)] 56 Galt-Barraud Medical Account Books, archives Colonial Williamsburg.
1804-1808:[Anthony Robinson in account with Galt & Barraud
p. 21 1804, November visits to wife and Betsy
p. 109 1806-1808 visits to wife]
1808-1814p. 21 [various visits to wife and Betsy]
1810-1811p. 121 [various visits to John and wife]
1813-1814p. 135 [visits to Betsy, Ponteaux and Jane]

Blueprint - digital version unavailable

58

Illustration #5

March 30th, 1959

To: Dr. E. M. Riley
From: I. Noël Hume
Re: Archaeological Area 2H11

The Chiswell-Bucktrout property was excavated in 1941 and the report written by Francis Duke. No artifacts are discussed nor is any indication of date provided. It is, however, suggested that the building would have been suitable for servants quarters. The relevant passage is as follows:

  • H-11 (see photographs N6704-5)
  • Farthest south in the line of outbuildings is a long foundation which contains indications of a large outside chimney at the north end and a double chimney near the south end. The building consisted of two divisions, a long north section with a 13" brick foundation and a short south section with a 9" foundation.
  • The south chimney has a small fireplace on its south side, and on the north a larger fireplace which is not, however, as large as that of the north chimney.
  • Though the location of this building would seem suitable for servant's quarter, the plan does not follow a common pattern.
  • Foundations similarly long and narrow, of as yet unknown purpose, have been found in the Taliaferro-Cole and Patsy Custis lots.
  • Brick-8 ¼" - 8 ½" x 4" x 2 5/8". Very hard, dark brick on north (exterior) chimney with soft red bricks on inside
    Mortar-Shell
    Condition-Bad

A search of the archaeological collections has revealed the bowl of an eighteenth-century pewter spoon, the bowl of a latten spoon with a triple spoon mark and dating from the late seventeenth or eighteenth century, as well as the bone back from a toothbrush of the first half (?) of the nineteenth century. The collection houses not one single ceramic fragment of any date, nor does it contain any items of glass or lead. Iron items comprise part of a bit (eighteenth century) two pieces of iron cooking pot and part of an HL hinge (almost certainly nineteenth century) and a large nail or spike of uncertain antiquity.

59

It is surprising that so large a building should have yielded so little. Nevertheless it might be assumed, on the evidence of the spoons, that the structure served a domestic rather than an industrial purpose. Such evidence alone is, of course, so slender as to be virtually useless. However, coupled with the absence of evidence indicating the presence of a cabinet-maker's workshop or powder-mill, it could conceivably be used to suggest that these operations were not carried out on this site.

I regret that we cannot be more positive.

I.N.H.

June 9, 1970

To: Mr. I. Noël Hume
From: Patricia Gibbs
Re: Additional information about lots in vicinity of Chiswell-Bucktrout House

Dr. Riley asked me to check for any information not included in the house histories of the lots in the vicinity of your dig behind the Chiswell-Bucktrout House.

As you know, the absence of early James City County records eliminates many of the possible sources for documentary evidence from the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries for this section of Williamsburg. Tracing the ownership of property in this area, without the benefit of deeds, complicated the writing of the house histories; consequently, the house histories are sketchy and based mainly on indirect information. I have checked the house histories for the section along the south side of Francis Street from the Chiswell-Bucktrout House east to the entrance to Bassett Hall. Though one might question certain conclusions in the house histories, the lack of direct evidence makes discounting these conclusions impossible. The following material includes information found since the house histories were written, combines references from separate house histories, and adds evidence which appears on maps of Williamsburg. Obvious discrepancies occur which might be made clearer if more records were available; however, all known sources have been checked.

A deed (1774) from Philip Ludwell Grymes to James Hubard for five lots - lots 252, 253, 801 [exact location unknown but possibly south of either lot 252 or lot 253], and two lots described as "that tract above granted Lots which was lately the Property of Philip Johnson" — was located in the loose papers of Fredericksburg District Court. These lots were bound "on the South by the Street Laid off by the said Johnson" [see appended deed].

The lots of Philip Johnson referred to in the 1774 deed appear east of Queen Street and below the lots bordering on the south of Francis Street on several maps of the city. The Tyler Map numbers the lots 1-34. The Bucktrout Map (1803) gives the same numbering (unless the numbers were added later). The Lively-Bucktrout Map (1867), like the 1803 map, identifies the lots as "Col. Philip Johnson's Lots, attached to the City—19 Acres and 26 poles, laid off into Lots as above" but does not number the lots. Two acts in Hening's Statutes at Large refer to the lots laid off by Philip Johnson: one dated 1758 states that the land was divided into thirty lots; the act dated 1761 refers to thirty-two lots [see appended Lively-Bucktrout Map and acts].

June 9, 1970

To: Mr. I. Noel Hume
From: Patricia Gibbs
Re: Additional information about lots in vicinity of Chiswell-Bucktrout House

Dr. Riley asked me to check for any information not included in the house histories of the lots in the vicinity of your dig behind the Chiswell-Bucktrout House.

As you know, the absence of early James City County records eliminates many of the possible sources for documentary evidence from the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries for this section of Williamsburg. Tracing the ownership of property in this area, without the benefit of deeds, complicated the writing of the house histories; consequently, the house histories are sketchy and based mainly on indirect information. I have checked the house histories for the section along the south side of Francis Street from the Chiswell-Bucktrout House east to the entrance to Bassett Hall. Though one might question certain conclusions in the house histories, the lack of direct evidence makes discounting these conclusions impossible. The following material includes information found since the house histories were written, combines references from separate house histories, and adds evidence which appears on maps of Williamsburg. Obvious discrepancies occur which might be made clearer if more records were available; however, all known sources have been checked.

A deed (1774) from Philip Ludwell Grymes to James Hubard for five lots - lots 252, 253, 801 [exact location unknown but possibly south of either lot 252 or lot 253], and two lots described as "that tract above granted Lots which was lately the Property of Philip Johnson" — was located in the loose papers of Fredericksburg District Court. These lots were bound "on the South by the Street Laid off by the said Johnson" [see appended deed].

The lots of Philip Johnson referred to in the 1774 deed appear east of Queen Street and below the lots bordering on the south of Francis Street on several maps of the city. The Tyler Map numbers the lots 1-34. The Bucktrout Map (1803) gives the same numbering (unless the numbers were added later). The Lively-Bucktrout Map (1867), like the 1803 map, identifies the lots as "Col. Philip Johnson's Lots, attached to the City—19 Acres and 26 poles, laid off into Lots as above" but does not number the lots. Two acts in Hening's Statutes at Large refer to the lots laid off by Philip Johnson: one dated 1758 states that the land was divided into thirty lots; the act dated 1761 refers to thirty-two lots [see appended Lively-Bucktrout Map and acts].

2

The street mentioned on the 1774 deed as the southern boundary does not appear on any of the above maps or in the acts quoted in Hening. Extending Ireland Street to the east would have given access to all of Johnson's lots. Evidence that Ireland Street extended to the east by 1873 appears in Deed Book I, pp. 433-434 [Williamsburg-James City County Courthouse]. The location of Joseph M. Walthall's house and lot which would have included at least on of John's lots, was described as bounded on the north by Francis Street, on the west by Queen Street, and on the south by Ireland Street.

The drawing of Williamsburg included in the Simcoe papers in our manuscript collection shows a street south of Francis Street which appears to run in front of Tazewell Hall. The undated map which identifies the public buildings, including the courthouse and hospital, was made sometime after 1774. Since some parts show great detail but other parts have obvious errors such as the location of Nicholson Street, it may be a composite drawing made from earlier sketches [see appended map].

The Southall Papers [a collection of late eighteenth and early nineteenth century material from the files of the Williamsburg lawyer George W. Southall] and the Finnie Accounts [accounts, 1776-1780, of William Finnie, District Quartermaster General] were checked for material relating to lots owned by Benjamin Bucktrout. The references in the Southall Papers to land owned by Benjamin Bucktrout concerned land outside of Williamsburg. One item of interest was located in this collection: an order for the sergeant to apply to Richard M. Bucktrout for the plan of the city drawn by his father in 1804. [see appended order]. Two entries for 1779 in the Finnie accounts refer to property of Benjamin Bucktrout in Williamsburg. On May 25th William Finnie, DQMG Accounts 1776-1780, Auditor's Item, Virginia State Archives].

No written evidence has been located to identify a tailor with the lot directly east of the Chiswell-Bucktrout House. In May, 1773m, Archibald Diddep, tailor, advertised that he had moved to a house next to Dr. Pasteur's [Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon, eds., May 13, 1773, p. 3]. Dr. William Pasteur was living in the Semple House at that time. Other advertisements and tax records place Diddep on lot 255, just west of the Semple House from 1773 until his death in 1785. Diddep is the only tailor we can identify with this section of Williamsburg. The tailor named Grymes whom Dr. Riley spoke to you about was John Grymes. We have only one reference to this man who did some work for the Burwell's at Carter's Grove from 1779-1782 [Ledger, 1779-1786, Burwell Papers, Colonial Williamsburg Incorporated].

Deed of Philip Ludwell Grymes to James Hubard

This indenture made the first day of November in the year of our Lord One thousand seven hundred and seventy four. Between Philip Ludwell Grymes Esqr. of Brandon in the County of Middlesex and Judith his Wife of the one part, and James Hubard of the City of Williamsburg of the other part. Witnesseth that the said Philip Ludwell Grymes Esqr. and Judith his wife for and in consideration of the sum of six hundred pounds Current money of Virginia to him and in hand by the said James Hubard at or before the ensealing and delivery of these presents, the receipt whereof he doth hereby acknowledge, and thereof doth acquit the said James Hubard his executors and Administrators, have and each of them hath granted, bargained, sold aliened, released and Confirmed and by these presents do grant, bargain, sell, alien, release and Confirm unto the said James Hubard his heirs and assigns forever, all that Messuage or Brick dwelling House situate on the South side of Francis Street in the City of Williamsburg, also three Lots of land on which or one of them the said dwelling House standeth and which said lots of Land are described in the plan of the said City by the figures 252. 801. and 253 and all houses outhouses buildings on the said Lots, or on either of them now standing or being and a seat or pew in the South Gallery of the Church of Bruton in the said City usually occupied by the family of the said Philip Ludwell Grymes Esqr. together with all Commodities, emoluments, profits and appurtenances whatsoever to the said granted Messuages and Lots of Land belonging or in any wise appertaining or therewith usually occupied, used, or enjoyed, or accepted reputed taken or known to be part or parcel thereof, and also all that tract or parcel of Land, situate lying and adjoining to the South of the three above granted Lots which was lately the Property of Philip Johnson, and bounded on the West by the lots of Richard Adams, and William Acrill Esquires, on the East by the lot of Benjamin Harrison Esqr. and on the South by the Street Laid off by the said Johnson, with all Houses thereon and also the reversion and reversions, remainder and remainders, rents and Services of the said premises, and all and every part thereof with all the estate right, title, Interest, Claim and demand whatsoever of him the said Philip Ludwell Grymes and Judith his Wife, of in and to the said Messuage page 2 Dwelling house and premises and every part and parcel thereof. To have and to hold the said Messuage and dwelling House and all and singular the said Lots and premises above mentioned and every part and parcel thereof with all the appurtenances unto the said James Hubard his heirs and assigns to the only proper use and behoof of him the said James Hubard his heirs and assigns forever. And the said Philip Ludwell Grymes for him and his heirs, the said Messuage or dwelling House and premises, and every part thereof, against him and his heirs, and against all and every other person and persons whatsoever to the said James Hubard his heirs and assigns, shall and will warrant and forever defend by these presents. And the said Philip Ludwell Grymes for himself and his heirs doth Covenant and agree with the said James Hubard his heirs and assigns that he will sign seal and execute any other Instrument of writing for the further Conveying and assuring the said Messuage or dwelling house and all the premises hereby granted unto the said James Hubard his heirs and assigns as he shall be desired for that purpose. And the said James Hubard doth convenant and agree for himself and his heirs and assigns to and with the said Philip Ludwell Grymes that he and his said wife shall have free liberty and permission to sit and use the seat or pew hereby granted to the said James Hubard in the Church of Bruton. In Witness whereof the parties to these presents, have subscribed their hands and affixed their Seals, the day and year above written.

Philip L Grymes SL
Judith Grymes SL

Sealed and delivered
In presence of
Thos. Nelson Junr., J. Ambler
Wm Rynolds, Thos. Everard

George the third by the Grace of God of Great Britain, France and Ireland, King defender of the Faith &c. To Thomas Nelson Junr. Jacquelin Ambler and William Rynolds Gent. Greetings. Whereas Philip Ludwell Grymes and Judith his wife by their certain Indenture of bargain and sale bearing date the first day of November 1774 have sold and conveyed unto James Hubard the fee simple estate of five Lots of Land with the appurtenances lying and being in the City of Williamsburg in the County of James City of which said Lots three are described in the plan of the said City of Williamsburg by the figures 252. 801 and 253, and whereas the said Judith Grymes cannot conveniently travel to our General Court of this Dominion to make acknowledgement of the said conveyance Therefore we do give unto you or any page 3 Two or more of you power to receive the acknowledgement which the said Judith shall be willing to make before you of the conveyance aforesaid, contained in the said Indenture which is hereunto annexed, and we do therefore command you that you do personally go to the said Judith and receive her acknowledgement of the same and examine her privily and apart from the said Philip her husband whether she doth the same freely and voluntarily without his persuasions or threats and whether she be willing that the same should be recorded in our said general Court and when you have received her acknowledgement and examined her as aforesaid that you disctinctly and openly Certify us thereof in our said General Court under your Seals sending then there the said Indenture and this Writ. Witness John Earl of Dunmore our Lieutenant and Governor General at Williamsburg the first day of November in the fifteenth year of our reign.
Ben. Waller

By Virtue of this Writ. We did go to the within named Judith and examined her priviliy and apart from Philip Ludwell Grymes her husband, and before us she acknowledged the Indenture annexed to be her act and deed and declared she did the same freely and voluntarily without the persuasions or threats of her husband and that she was willing the same should be recorded in the General Court. Certified under our hands and seals this 4th day of February 1775.
Thos. Nelson Junr. SL
J. Ambler SL

Virginia to wit
At a General Court held at the Capitol the 17th day of April 1775. This Indenture was proved by the Oaths of Thomas Nelson Junr. William Rynolds and Thomas Everard Witnesses thereto, and together with the commission annexed, and the certificate of the execution thereof, Ordered to be recorded.
Teste
Ben. Waller C.G.C.

A Copy,
Teste
Peyton Drew C.G.C.

page 4

[endorsed]
1775 Book 29, page 637
Grymes & Wife
To Copy Deed
Hubard

Fee per deed1.57
" Commn.52
$2.09

Mr. And Mrs. Grymes were well known residents of Middlesex and Genl Thos Nelson & Mr. Ambler inhabitants of York and magistrates of York County.

Swann
Vs
Seldon

Extd by deft
W.C. Seldon
Octo: 11: 1830

Source:

  • Loose Papers, Fredericksburg District Court.
    Submittd by George H.S. King
    1303 Prince Edward Street
    Fredericksburg, Virginia 22401
    11 August 1967

RR101709Plot of the City of Williamsburg

Hening's, Statutes at Large…, Vol. VII, pp. 247-248.

An Act for vesting certain lands therein mentioned in Philip Johnson, gentleman, adding the same to the City of Williamsburg, and for other purposes therein mentioned. [1758]

I. WHEREAS John Robinson, esquire, is and stands seized of divers lands and tenements, in the parish of Bruton, in the county of James City, in trust, as to one moiety thereof for the use of Philip Johnson, gentleman, during his natural life, and after his decease, in trust, and to and for the use of such child or children as he now hath or may have by Elizabeth his present wife, daughter of Thomas Bray, gentleman, deceased, to whom he shall give or devise the same by deed or will, subject nevertheless to the dower of the said Elizabeth; and as to the other moiety thereof, in trust, and to and for the use of the said Philip Johnson, his heirs and assigns for ever, in case he shall pay unto such child or children of him and the said Elizabeth, notwithstanding her coverture, shall, by any deed or instrument in writing, duly executed by her, give, direct, and appoint, according to the proviso; and his covenant contained in an indenture of release, bearing date the twenty-second day of October, one thousand seven hundred and fifty-one, made between the said Philip Johnson and Elizabeth his wife, of the one part, and the said John Robinson and Elizabeth his wife, of the other part, which indenture is now remaining on record in the secretary's office, but in case he shall not pay such money then in trust, and to and for the use of such child or children as aforesaid, to whom the said Elizabeth, by such deed or instrument in writing, shall give, direct, and appoint the same; and in case the said Elizabeth shall execute no such deed or instrument, then in trust, and to and for the use of the said Philip Johnson, during his natural life, and after his decease, in trust, and to and for the use of such child or children as the said Philip Johnson now hath or hereafter may have by the said Elizabeth, to whom he shall give or devise the same by deed or will as aforesaid, and to the heirs and assigns of such child or children, subject nevertheless to the dower of the said Elizabeth.

II. And whereas it hath been represented to this general assembly by the said Philip Johnson, that he hath laid off seventeen acres and 26 poles of the said trust land, adjoining the southern bounds of the city of Williamsburg, into thirty lots, which he is desirous may be added to and made part of the said city: And the said Philip Johnson being seized in fee simple for forty-three acres of land, with the appurtenances, late the estate of one John Baskerfield, lying in the said parish of Bruton, and county of James City, contiguous to the said trust lands, and of greater value than the said seventeen acres and 26 poles so laid off into lots, Which he is willing should be settled in lieu thereof: Be it therefore enacted, by the Lieutenant-Governor, Council, and Burgesses, of this present General Assembly, and it is hereby enacted, by the authority of the same, that the said seventeen acres and twenty-six poles of land, adjoining the southern bounds of the said city of Williamsburg, shall be, and the same are hereby vested in the said Philip Johnson, his heirs and assigns; and that the said forty-three acres of land, with the appurtenances, lying in the said parish of Bruton, and county of James City, late the estate of the said John Baskerfield, shall be, and the same are hereby vested in the said John Robinson, his heirs and assigns, in trust, and to and for the same uses that he is and now stands seized of the residue of the said trust lands.

III. And be it further enacted, by the authority aforesaid, That the said seventeen acres and twenty-six poles of land, so laid off by the said Philip Johnson into lots, adjoining the said city of Williamsburg, so soon as the said lots shall respectively be built upon, and saved according to the conditions that shall be contained in the deeds of conveyance thereof, shall be added to and made part of the said city; and the freeholders and inhabitants of the said lots shall then be entitled to, and enjoy all the rights, privileges, and immunities granted to and enjoyed by the freeholders and inhabitants of the said city, and shall be subject to the same jurisdiction, rules and government with the other inhabitants of the said city.

Hening's, Statutes at Large…, Vol. VII, pp.452-454.

An Act for vesting certain lands therein-mentioned in Philip Johnson, gentleman, adding the same to the City of Williamsburg, and for other purposes therein mentioned. [1761]

I. WHEREAS John Robinson, Esq. is and stands seized of divers lands and tenements in the Parish of Bruton, in the county of James City, in trust, as to one moiety thereof for the use of Philip Johnson, gentleman, during his natural life and after his decease in trust, and to and for the use of such child or children as he now hath or may have by Elizabeth his present wife, daughter of Thomas Bray, gentleman, deceased, to whom he shall give or devise the same by deed or Will, subject nevertheless to the power of the said Elizabeth; and as to the other moiety thereof in trust, and to and for the use of the said Philip Johnson, his heirs and assigns forever, in case he shall pay unto such child or children of him and the said Elizabeth all and every such sum and sums of money as the said Elizabeth, notwithstanding her coverture, shall by any deed or instrument in writing duly executed by her give, direct and appoint, according to the proviso and his covenant, contained in an indenture of release, bearing date the twenty-second day of October, one thousand seven hundred and fifty-one, made between the said Philip Johnson and Elizabeth his wife of the one part, and the said John Robinson of the other part, which indenture is now remaining of record in the Secretary's office; but in case he shall not pay such money then in trust, and to and from the use and behoof of such said child or children as aforesaid, to whom the said Elizabeth by such deed or instrument in Writing shall give, direct and appoint, the same; and in case the said Elizabeth shall execute no such deed or instrument in Writing shall give, direct and appoint, the same; and in case the said Elizabeth shall execute no such deed or instrument then in trust, and to and for the use of the said Philip Johnson during his natural life, and after his decease in trust, and to and for the use of such child or children as the said Philip Johnson now hath or hereafer may have by the said Elizabeth, to whom he shall give or devise the same by deed or will as aforesaid, and to the heirs and assigns of such child or children, subject nevertheless to the power of the said Elizabeth.

II. And whereas it hath been represented to this general assembly, by the said Philip Johnson, that he hath laid off nineteen acres and twenty-six poles pf the said trust land, adjoining the southern bounds of the city of Williamsburg, into thirty-two lots, Which he is desirous may be added to and made part of the said city; and that the said Philip Johnson is seized in fee simple of forty-three acres of land, with the appurtenances, late the estate of one John Baskerfield, lying, in the said parish of Bruton and county of James City, contiguous to the said trust lands, and of great value than the said nineteen acres and twenty six poles so laid off into lots, which he is willing should be settled in lieu thereof.

III. And whereas notice hath been published three Sundays successively, in the church of the said Parish of Bruton, that application would be made to this present general assembly, to vest the said nineteen acres and twenty-six poles of land in the said Philip Johnson in fee-simple, and to settle the said forty-three acres of land in lieu thereof, pursuant to your Majesty's instructions: may it therefore please your most excellent majesty, at the humble suit of the said Philip Johnson, that it may be enacted, and Be it enacted by the Lieutenant-Governor, Council, and Burgesses, of this present General Assembly, and it is hereby enacted, by the authority of the same. That the said nineteen acres and twenty-six poles of land, adjoining the southern bounds of the said city of Williamsburg, shall be, and the same are hereby, vested in the said Philip Johnson, his heirs & assigns for ever; and that the said forty-three acres of land, with the appurtenaces, lying in the said parish of Bruton and county of James City, late the estate of the said John Baskerfield, shall be, and the same are hereby, vested in the said John Robinson, his heirs and assigns, in trust, and to and for the same uses that he is and now stands seized of the residue of the said trust lands.

IV. And be it further enacted, by the authority aforesaid, That the said nineteen acres and twenty-six poles of land, so laid off by the said Philip Johnson into lots, adjoining the said City of Williamsburg, so soon as the said lots shall respectively be built on and saved according to the conditions that shall be contained in the deeds of conveyance thereof, shall be added to and made part of the said city; and the freeholders and inhabitants of the said lots shall then be entitled to, and enjoy, all the rights, privileges and immunities, granted to and enjoyed by the freeholders and inhabitants of the said city, and shall be subject to the same jurisdiction, rules and government, with the other inhabitants of the said city.

V. Saving to the King's most excellent majesty, his heirs and successours, and to all and every other person and persons, bodies politick and corporate, their respective heirs and successours, other than the persons claiming under the trust aforesaid, all such right, title, interest, property, claim and demand, as they, every, or any of them, should or might have had or claimed if this act had never been made.

VI. Provided always, That the execution of this act shall be, and the same is hereby, suspended, until his majesty's approbation thereof shall be obtained.

RR101710Simcoe Papers 1781-1806

RR101711Southall Papers
Folder 197

Manuscript

Footnotes

^1. We do not know the date of Benjamin Bucktrout's birth; nor do we know the exact date of his death, which occurred ca. 1813. He was commissioner of taxes for Williamsburg from 1802-1812, and paid taxes on his own property up to that date. In 1813 his property tax was charged against his "Estate." (Williamsburg Land Tax Records.)
Bucktrout married Mary Bruce of "the Parish of Bruton and County of York," in 1797. This was his second marriage. In 1797 Mrs. Peachy Wills spoke of him as a widower courting Miss Bruce. They had four children: Horatio, who married and lived in Norfolk; Rachel who married Hipolite Reptan and had one child, Rachel Reptan; Richard M. Bucktrout, who married 1st Delia Higgins and had Delia and Mary Elizabeth Bucktrout, and 2nd Celestia Lindsay, and had Horatio Bucktrout; and Benjamin Bucktrout, who married Louisanna Cosby and had four children. (Name Data File — information from Mrs. Virginia Haughwout of Williamsburg, a descendant.)
^1. There was at least one other cabinet-maker in Williamsburg at this time: Peter Scott, who had been living in Williamsburg for some forty years when he died in 1775 — and whose house and shop were opposite to Bruton Church.
^2. A number of other cabinet makers advertised in Williamsburg between the years 1771-1777: Edmund Dickinson, 1771-1775; Richard Booker, 1773-1776; Widdatch & Drummond "near Williamsburg," 1774; Honey & Horrocks (James Honey & Richard Horrocks) 1776.